Change Requests


Sign in if you wish to make any changes (editors only)

Click on Change no. for more details...

Change no.Hill no.Hill nameReq. dateByStatusDescription
1141817918Asparagus Island19/10/2018DMRevised
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12882. Adding decimal
heights for summit and col from LIDAR analysis. CC:
correcting Classification field
1141714812Bryn Glyn Uchaf19/10/2018JimRevised
(Agree=2)
Demotion & minor relocation. New replacement Tump to follow.
Change linked to GR update ref 12885. Relocation suggested
by Myrddyn Phillips. LIDAR. Add replacement hill number to
Comment. GG: adding col GR8 from LIDAR, col height okay
114165597Pole Hill19/10/2018DMRevised
(Agree=4)
Change linked to GR update ref 12884 Adding decimal height
from LIDAR analysis - edge of clearing
1141518722Gull Rock19/10/2018DMRevised
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12883 Adding decimal height
from LIDAR analysis
1141418564Silver Hill18/10/2018DMRevised
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12881 Adding decimal height
from LIDAR analysis.
114133190Sgurr a' Chlaidheimh West Top17/10/2018JimRevised
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12868. alda surveys
114123187Sgurr a' Chlaidheimh17/10/2018JimRevised
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12867. alda surveys
11411745Sgurr nan Eugallt East Top17/10/2018JimRevised
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12866. alda surveys
11410744Sgurr nan Eugallt17/10/2018JimRevised
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12865. alda summit survey
114092970Meall an Odhar17/10/2018JimRevised
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12864. alda surveys. Name
change to align with OS - spotted by alda
114082965An Grianan17/10/2018JimRevised
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12863. alda surveys (&
relocation)
11407120Stuchd an Lochain [Stuc an Lochain]17/10/2018JimRequested
(Agree=3)
Name priority swap to align with OS 50K & 25K. Spotted by
alda
11406NH359521Meall nan Damh East Top16/10/2018JimRejected
(Agree=1)
Potential new Subsimm spotted by chalky53. Jim & Chris
disagree - proceed with care
11405 (New)Cadhachan Riabhach West Top16/10/2018JimRevised
(Agree=2)
New Subsimm spotted by chalky53
11404 (New)Meall a' Choire Ghlais16/10/2018JimRevised
(Agree=3)
New Subsimm spotted by chalky53
114036419Sgurr an Ursainn West Top16/10/2018JimRequested
(Agree=2)
Name tweak - see previous CRs
1140219164Sgurr an Ursainn Far West Top16/10/2018JimRequested
(Agree=2)
Name tweak - see previous CR
11401 (New)Sgurr an Ursainn Far West Top16/10/2018JimRevised
(Agree=3)
New Subsimm spotted by chalky53. Consequential name changes
114007487Staerough Hill16/10/2018JimRequested
(On Hold)
Looks as high/higher than flush bracket at 131.6m on photo.
Col might be lower than 233m - hoping to arrange a survey.
113997485Wolfelee Hill15/10/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
averaging OS_M/Geograph at col
113987121Am Meall15/10/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
col position tweak - OS_M
113975999Creag Dhubh15/10/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
col position tweak from OS_M
113966593Beinn an Rubha Riabhaich15/10/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
OS_M col re-evaluation. Geograph confused by knoll in col??
Elsewhere hereabouts photogrammetric heights very close
113952789Fountains Fell South Top13/10/2018DMApplied
(Agree=4)
Change linked to GR update ref 0. Adding GR8 for col and
col height. Adding decimal height for summit.
1139419014Thundersley Hill13/10/2018DMApplied
(Agree=4)
Change linked to GR update ref 12848. Adding decimal height
from LIDAR analysis.
1139314790Bryn-mawr13/10/2018GGApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12847, adding LIDAR heights
113925449North's Seat12/10/2018DMApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12846. Add decimal height
from LIDAR.
1139118087Maes Knoll12/10/2018DMApplied
(Agree=3)
Tump deletion. Relocation to natural summit. Change linked
to GR update ref 12815. LIDAR
1139018622Stocks Hill11/10/2018DMApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12814. LIDAR
1138919181Havengore Island11/10/2018CCApplied
(Agree=4)
Change linked to GR update ref 12813. LIDAR
1138819183Wallasea Island10/10/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12808. LIDAR data. Road
treated as an embankment rather than a causeway for col
determination; natural col bridged. Jim: deleting TZ13
11387NJ958471Parkhouse Hill10/10/2018CCRejected
(Agree=2)
Possible Tump rejected on LIDAR. Summit in trees but only
15m from edge of wood where ground is 121.2m.
1138615394Llantydwell Hill09/10/2018CCApplied
(Agree=2)
LIDAR update prompted by M Phillips survey
1138517929Withypool Hill09/10/2018CCApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12803. LIDAR summit 399.3 but
the 3 GPS submissions agree on a different loc where LIDAR
gives 389.9-399.0
1138414308Kirk Hill08/10/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12778. LIDAR
1138314303St Abb's Head08/10/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12777. LIDAR
1138218861Cleaver Rock08/10/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12776. LIDAR. col=1.0m
1138114314Foul Carr08/10/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12775. LIDAR
1138018860Downie's Goats [Crooked Carr]08/10/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12774. LIDAR. Adding old maps
name (DG may refer to headland 60m N). Tidal range at
Alnmouth <6m. Not an island
1137914316West Hurker08/10/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Tump deletion. Change linked to GR update ref 12773. LIDAR
is 29.69/1.14. In this steep environment LIDAR can
underestimate summit height and col depth - on balance
unlikely to be sufficient to make this P30. No decimals
used.
1137818859Little Channeler08/10/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
New hill to fill vacant slot. Change linked to GR update ref
12772. LIDAR. Probably tidal on balance, col <0m. New
Comment ignores designation over last 7 months.
1137714315Skelly08/10/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12771. LIDAR. Tidal/non -
tidal question unresolved. Sticking with non - tidal as
shown on old maps. col<0m.
1137618862Floater Rock08/10/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12770. LIDAR. Photos indicate
there is continuous 'air' between Floater & Skelly
1137517504Black Hill07/10/2018CCApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12768; LIDAR data
1137417498Bellever Tor07/10/2018CCApplied
(Agree=2)
LIDAR update. DSM summit at Abneyed loc, W top 52cm lower.
DTM has chopped off the summit tor.
1137315597Ynys-fach07/10/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
LIDAR update and Parent mod, col>0m
113724856Island Davaar07/10/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Parent mod, col>0m
1137111312Eilean Mhic Chrion07/10/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Parent mod, col>0m
1137019052Eilean Ighe07/10/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Parent mod, col>0m
1136919352Le Puits Gervais07/10/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
no evidence that col>0m
1136819351Fourquie07/10/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
no evidence that col>0m
1136719350La Nace07/10/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
no evidence that col>0m
1136619441 (New)Tormollan Hill06/10/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
New Tump spotted by Dazingdale
1136517487Birch Tor05/10/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
Adding LIDAR height, summit at Abneyed loc, assumes tumulus
covers natural summit. No LIDAR at col.
1136416545Ely Brow05/10/2018CCApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12759. LIDAR heights.
1136316369Moughton05/10/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12758. Adding LIDAR heights
1136218358Castle Rock04/10/2018DMApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12756. Adding decimal height
from LIDAR CC: updating obs and deleting comment
113612888Beacon Hill (Lundy)04/10/2018DMApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12749. Adding decimal height
from LIDAR
1136019314Flory Island04/10/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12755. New LIDAR?? col now at
2.43m on DTM/DSM (reported as being 1.6 in 2017). Leaving
summit undecimalised.
1135918756Porth Island04/10/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12754. LIDAR. col<0m but
definitely tidal
1135818747Zacry's Island North04/10/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12753. LIDAR.
1135718746Zacry's Island South04/10/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 0. LIDAR evaluation (GR10
unchanged). Col <0m
1135616363Warrendale Knotts03/10/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
LIDAR update. Summit loc agrees with Abney.
1135519231Carnewas Island03/10/2018JimRejected
(Agree=2)
col re-evaluation from OS_M - Geograph doesn't contradict.
Jim: LIDAR shows 14.7/51.3 therefore no change necessary
1135418764Lower Merope Island03/10/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12752. LIDAR S & C. Only just
an island (tidal range 7.5m).
1135318763Middle Merope Island03/10/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12751. LIDAR data
1135218765Higher Merope Island03/10/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
LIDAR 39.192, col sea, borderline tidal (leaving unchanged).
GRUpdate done separately. Pointy summit - could be higher -
therefore no decimal
1135119423Geodha Brat North02/10/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
col position shown erroneously - no evidence that it is >0m
1135019090Read's Island02/10/2018DMRejected
(Agree=1)
SIMON - raised in error please delete
1134919436Bow Fiddle02/10/2018DMRejected
(Agree=1)
Change linked to GR update ref 12745. Addition of decimal
height from LIDAR
1134815598New Quay Stack30/09/2018CCApplied
(Agree=2)
Tump deletion prompted by M Phillips LIDAR analysis
1134718573Court-at-Street Hill30/09/2018DMApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12740. Addition of decimal
height from LIDAR
1134618507Summerhouse Hill29/09/2018DMApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12737. Adding decimal height
from LIDAR
1134516774Fober Knoll29/09/2018GGApplied
(Agree=2)
height revision prompted by LIDAR analysis, tree cover
negates decimal height
113446005Morrone South Top29/09/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12735. alda survey
11343444Morrone29/09/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12734. alda survey
11342SZ493879Mount Joy29/09/2018GGRejected
(Agree=1)
Tump suggested by Stephen Walker, rejected on map and LIDAR
analysis
1134118458Swinge Hill28/09/2018DMApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12730. Addition of decimal
height from LIDAR analysis
11340SX469528Drake's Island28/09/2018CCRejected
(Agree=2)
Potential island Tump suggested by Chris Pearson rejected on
LIDAR
1133918322Steep Holm27/09/2018DMApplied
(Agree=4)
Change linked to GR update ref 12727. Adding decimal height
from LIDAR analysis
1133815423Brynhyfryd27/09/2018CCApplied
(Agree=2)
Tump deletion prompted by LIDAR analysis by M Phillips
1133719437 (New)Craig-y-borion24/09/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
New Tump identified by Myrddyn Phillips.
113365016Cairngryffe Hill (quarried)24/09/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12717
1133519086Moncreiffe Island24/09/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
transfer to new Maritime Area
1133424/09/2018JimApplied
(Agree=1)
SIB v10 Maritime Area changes: J018 Eddrachillis Bay
(delete - South) J026 Forth: River & Firth (separation of
Forth & Tay) J068 Thames & The Medway (delete Estuary) Add
new area J071 Tay: Arbroath to Fife Ness
1133319439 (New)Hoo Island23/09/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
New SIB v10. Data from LIDAR.
1133212791Bhalaigh23/09/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
changing to tidal to align with SIB v10
1133118826Fugla Stack23/09/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
New SIB v10
1133012094Muckle Hallitie23/09/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
new SIB v10
1132920019Cnoc na Toinne22/09/2018DMApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12701. Addition of GR8 for
col
1132820010The Big Gun [An Gunna Mor]22/09/2018DMApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12697. Addition of GR8 for
col.
113272496Grange Fell [Brund Fell]22/09/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
Update from LIDAR. Rock Tor in Observations is 1.7m lower.
1132619438 (New)Dunbar's Stack22/09/2018JimApplied
(Agree=4)
New Tump from Chris Pearson - LIDAR
1132519440 (New)Andersey Island22/09/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
New SIB identified by Chris Pearson. LIDAR GR10s for both
points to be entered (Comment can then be removed)
11324SJ104509Coed Hendre-Isaf22/09/2018CCRejected
(Agree=2)
Potential Tump from SRTM data (row 210), rejected on LIDAR.
Summit at SJ 10465 50986
11323SO854633Gardner's Hill22/09/2018CCRejected
(Agree=2)
Potential Tump near Droitwich from SRTM data (row 138)
rejected on LIDAR. Summit 30m N of trig
11322SX553679Sheeps Tor West Top22/09/2018CCRejected
(Agree=2)
Potential Tump from SRTM dataset (row 306) rejected on
LIDAR. Given as example in S&C of dam over col.
1132119137Lochurd Hills22/09/2018SEApplied
(Agree=3)
Section correction spotted by Dave Geere
1132019436 (New)Bow Fiddle21/09/2018JimApplied
(Agree=4)
LIDAR evaluation of Chris Pearson suggestion
1131919435 (New)Na Gilleachan Ruadh21/09/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New Tump from Chris Pearson - OSM
1131819434 (New)Raga Wick North21/09/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New Tump from Chris Pearson - OSM (poor name)
1131719433 (New)Raga Wick Far North21/09/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New Tump from Chris Pearson - OSM (poor name)
1131619432 (New)Da Stacks o da Logat16/09/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New Tump from Chris Pearson - OSM Previously rejected in
CR3732
1131519431 (New)Da Stab16/09/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New Tump from Chris Pearson - OSM
1131419430 (New)Faither Stack15/09/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New Tump from Chris Pearson - 1:25,000
1131319429 (New)South Headland Preshal Beg15/09/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New Tump from Chris Pearson - OSM
1131219428 (New)Dun nam Fiann15/09/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New Tump from Chris Pearson - OSM
1131119427 (New)Monadh Dubh Stack15/09/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New Tump from Chris Pearson - on balance of OSM evidence.
MHWS-MLWS=4.2m
1131019426 (New)Dun Mor15/09/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New Tump from Chris Pearson - OSM
1130919425 (New)Stack Clo Kervaig15/09/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New Tump from Chris Pearson - OSM
1130819424 (New)Dunan Mor Stack15/09/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New Tump from Chris Pearson - OSM (poor name) - tiny 30m
contour
1130719423 (New)Geodha Brat North15/09/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New Tump from Chris Pearson - OSM (poor name?)
1130619422 (New)Uamh Dhonn Stack15/09/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
New Tump from Chris Pearson - OSM
1130519421 (New)Rubha Dubh East15/09/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New Tump from Chris Pearson - OSM
1130419420 (New)Clett15/09/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New Tump from Chris Pearson - OSM
1130319419 (New)Sweinn Geo North15/09/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New Tump from Chris Pearson - on balance of OSM evidence. At
ND 23683 91568
1130219418 (New)Sweinn Geo Far North15/09/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New Tump from Chris Pearson - OSM
11301ND234921Green Heads Stack15/09/2018JimRejected
(Agree=1)
Serious Stac Tump candidate - insufficient evidence on OSM
alone. At ND 23417 92185. From Chris Pearson.
11300ND232931Robie Geo South15/09/2018JimRejected
(Agree=1)
Serious Stac Tump candidate - insufficient evidence on
OSM alone. At ND 23216 93177. From Chris Pearson.
11299ND232931Robie Geo North15/09/2018JimRejected
(Agree=1)
Serious Stac Tump candidate - insufficient evidence on OSM
alone. At ND 23217 93189. From Chris Pearson.
112982531Green Side [White Stones - Green Side]14/09/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
Simm/Hewitt deletion following alda LIDAR study
112972522Striding Edge [High Spying How]13/09/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12676. alda LIDAR study - new
Simm and Hewitt
112965746Beinn an Fhogharaidh13/09/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
OSM suggests col is 599/600 but is reading a little high.
Averaging after reviewing Geograph. Spotted by alda
112957857Carn Cadha an Eididh12/09/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Assuming Cadh is a typo and Cadha (2 out of 3) is correct -
spotted by alda. Correct gaelic maybe Carn Cadh' an Eididh
but this does not appear on any (current) map.
1129419414 (New)Brock Crags12/09/2018CCApplied
(Agree=2)
Splitting out the Subdodd from the W/B/Sy/Fe. Data from
LIDAR.
112936931Beinn Bhuidhe10/09/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
col GR tweak from OSM
112927073Strone Hill10/09/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
col GR tweak from OSM
112916732Creag nan Speireag10/09/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
col height tweak (OSM371). Averaging but OSM reading about
0.5m high (therefore 369, not 370)
112906898Egnaig Hill10/09/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
21 OSM contours. New Hump (photogrammetry plates fairly well
aligned)
112897078Muskna Field10/09/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
21 contour rings on OSM. New Hump
112885006Mounthuillie09/09/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
col re-evaluation. Geo/OSM both with 5m contours - averaging
Geo (132), OSM (136)
112876899Shona Beag [Eilean Shona]09/09/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
OSM indicates our col depth is exaggerated
112862582Brock Crags (Wainwright)08/09/2018GJApplied
(Agree=2)
Moving the s5 to a new hill following LIDAR analysis.
Comment needs editing.
112851048Toman Coinnich [Toman Coinich]08/09/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
OSM indicates there is a knoll in the col and the 869 spot
height refers to the knoll's summit. Spotted by alda
112846595Bad a' Chlamhain08/09/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Proposed for Hump status by MJ in 2011. Evidence deemed
insufficient at that time. 2018 OSM very supportive - new
Hump
112831212Stac Pollaidh06/09/2018GJApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12651
112822070Waun Garnedd-y-Filiast06/09/2018GJApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12650
112816226Cam Sgriob05/09/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Col re-appraisal. New Hump. Original col position based on
25K 490m contours. OSM, with 5m contours, indicates that the
Geograph 384m spot height (200m W) is indeed at the col
(despite the fact that it looks an aberration on Geograph).
112803079Ben Earb05/09/2018JimApplied
(Agree=4)
Change linked to GR update ref 12646. alda survey
11279447Meall Uaine05/09/2018JimApplied
(Agree=4)
Change linked to GR update ref 12645. alda survey
11278SW340246Armed Knight05/09/2018CCRejected
(Agree=2)
Cornish sea stack suggested by Chris Pearson, rejected as
Tump on LIDAR
1127719417 (New)Devil's Chimney05/09/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
New Tump suggested by Chris Pearson. Sea stack on Lundy
coast. Col height close to MHWS - balance of evidence
(photographic and tide data) suggests this is probably a
tidal Mono Tump island rather than a 2nd Tump on Lundy -
note Comment
1127619416 (New)Bosistow Island05/09/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
New Tump in Cornwall suggested by Chris Pearson. Sea stack.
DSM 1m resolution, summit could be higher as steep rock.
11275735Stob a' Choire Odhair04/09/2018DMApplied
(Agree=4)
Change linked to GR update ref 0
11274836Carn na Con Dhu04/09/2018DMApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12632
112731040Sgurr Mor29/08/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
Summit tweak. Average of the 1108 and 1110 air heights is
the same as the old trig.
1127218659Gewni28/08/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
Tweak from LIDAR prompted by M Phillips analysis. Sea level
averages -1.3m out to sea. CC: adding parent
1127119415 (New)Gwaun-Cae-Gurwen Common28/08/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
New Tump suggested by Chris Pearson. Reclaimed spoil tip.
Current opencast workings are the other side of the col.
Name from council publication. 25/9: moved to SE summit. Rob
W's GPS measurements for this and 2 alt summits to go in.
112706633Beinn Bhan North Top27/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12582. alda survey
112696635Beinn Bhan Far North Top27/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12581. alda survey
112681019Beinn Tarsuinn27/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12580. alda survey
11267SX050870Trebarwith Slate Quarry27/08/2018GGRejected
(Agree=2)
new hill suggested by Chris Pearson, rejected on LIDAR
analysis
11266SK030825Delabole Stack27/08/2018GGRejected
(Agree=2)
new hill suggested by Chris Pearson, rejected on LIDAR
analysis
112656662Suidheachan Fhinn27/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12562. alda survey
1126426/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change 28 hills from Parent (Ma) 2105 to 19xxx Foel Cedig.
Ensure Foel Cedig is the 29th and modify the Parent (Ma) in
CR11262 (this is 1 of the 28).
1126319413 (New)Foel Cedig26/08/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
Marilyn, Simm and Nuttall relocated from 2105 Cyrniau Nod
following Trimble survey by Myrddyn Phillips.
112622105Cyrniau Nod26/08/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
Marilyn/Simm/Nuttall deletion following survey by Myrddyn
Phillips. Alternative col at SH987282 has 659m spot on
Geograph. Comment to be edited when new hill no. known
1126119412 (New)Dun Sgurabhal25/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
New Tump following visit by Adrian & Alex C. 4 reversed GPS
readings by chalky54 average P37. 1 reversed altimeter
reading from Colin Crawford averages P35.5. chalky54
reports that summit position coincides with tiny contour
ring supporting 7 OSM contours conclusion. Absolute heights
from OSM
112605916Garbh Mheall Mor25/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12549. alda survey
112593020Beinn Pharlagain25/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12548. alda survey and
request for name change
11258374Beinn Pharlagain - Meall na Meoig [Meall na Meoig]25/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12547. alda summit survey
(GR10 unchanged). Simm renamed Meall na Meoig, Ben now only
given in Munro's Tables
112575920Beinn Pharlagain South Top25/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12546. alda survey and name
change resulting from 3020 renaming. Subsimm deletion
1125619411 (New)Meall a' Charra24/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
New Subsimm spotted by alda. Five contour rings on OSM
1125519410 (New)Grower Rock21/08/2018GGApplied
(Agree=2)
new Tump spotted by Chris Pearson, rounding summit up to 40m
as LIDAR may miss highest point
11254SJ506819Runcorn Hill19/08/2018GGRejected
(Agree=1)
new hill suggested by Derek Kettlewell, rejected on LIDAR
data analysis
1125315971Sappers' Pike17/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Catchment inherent contradiction. Can't be in Minor Rivers
only and Tyne (Newcastle).
1125215979Mount Gilbert17/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Catchment inherent contradiction. Can't be in Minor
Rivers only and Tyne (Newcastle).
1125115950Darden Rigg17/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Catchment inherent contradiction. Can't be in Minor
Rivers only and Coquetdale.
1125016048Beacon Hill17/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Catchment inherent contradiction. Can't be in Minor
Rivers only and Coquetdale.
1124916009Coldrife Hill17/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Catchment inherent contradiction. Can't be in Minor
Rivers only and Coquetdale.
112482315Tosson Hill17/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Catchment inherent contradiction. Can't be in Minor Rivers
only and Coquetdale.
11247SW929806Pentire Head15/08/2018DMRejected
(Agree=4)
new hill suggested by Chris Pearson, rejected on LIDAR
analysis
11246SW932811The Rumps15/08/2018GGRejected
(Agree=3)
new hill suggested by David Gradwell, rejected on LIDAR data
analysis
112452337High Pike (Caldbeck)10/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
G&J col survey
112442343Miller Moss [Little Lingy Hill]10/08/2018GJApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12474
112432454Illgill Head10/08/2018GJApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12473
1124217013Brynspeard Hill10/08/2018SEApplied
(Agree=4)
Hill name change spotted by Paul Grantham (Brynspard on old
LR161 and all older maps)
1124119230Porthmoina Island05/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=4)
col data from Alan Holmes review
112402178Great Rhos02/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Col swap with 2182 Pegwn Mawr following careful study and
survey by Myrddyn Phillips
112392182Pegwn Mawr02/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Col swap with 2178 Great Rhos following careful study and
survey by Myrddyn Phillips
1123819409 (New)The Sugarloaf02/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
IoM seastack. LIDAR data from Department of Infrastucture,
Douglas - procured by the efforts of Darren Giddins
1123719283North Gaulton Castle01/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
site visit to adjacent cliffs by RHW - comparison with
Mainland contours and hand held GPS suggest 35m. No mapping
evidence found
112366684Cnoc a' Bhaid-rallaich West Top01/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12374. alda survey
11235954Liathach - Mullach an Rathain01/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12373. alda survey. col swap
11234967Am Fasarinen01/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12372. alda survey. col swap
(see next CR)
1123319408 (New)Mullach an Rathain East Top01/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda survey of new Subsimm
112323676Mullach an Rathain Far East Top01/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12371. alda survey. Name
change to accommodate next CR
1123118784Am Bodach01/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New parent (Ma)
1123010021Dunan Beag01/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New parent (Ma)
1122918771Geodha Glas Head01/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New parent (Ma)
112284727Dunan Mor01/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New parent (Ma)
112279633Sithean na h-Iolaireich01/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New parent (Ma)
112269855Cnoc Loch na Seamraig01/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New parent (Ma)
1122518785Stac Geodha Cul an Fhraochaidh01/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New parent (Ma)
112241121Cnoc a' Ghiubhais01/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New parent (Ma)
112239712Cnoc an t-Socaich Ghlais01/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New parent (Ma)
112229635Maovally More01/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New parent (Ma)
112219719Cnoc a' Gheodha Ruaidh01/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New parent (Ma)
112206774Cnoc na Glaic Tarsuinn01/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New parent (Ma)
112191117Beinn Dearg01/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12370. Jon Metcalfe survey.
New Marilyn
112184927Old Man of Hoy30/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Col height: OSM and Geograph (both with 5m contours)
indicate between 15 and 20m. Site visit by RichardM & RHW
propose 21/22m from altimeter readings. Adding 4m as
sensible compromise.
112174388Sgurr na Bana Mhoraire29/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12361. alda survey. alda
reports - Map has 588m at col indicating drop of 99m. This
looks in the right place on the map but there is lower
ground to the south and east near a small unmapped lochan
where the ridge line flattens out.
112166632Spidean Toll nam Biast29/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12360
112153252Creagan Dubh Toll nam Biast29/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12359. alda survey
112143268Creag a' Choire Ghranda29/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12348. alda survey. Retiral
of old South Top name
112134426Carn Loch nan Eilean [Leac an Tuadh]29/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12347. alda summit survey.
Summit renamed by OS - spotted by alda
112126714Beinn Dearg West Top29/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12346. alda survey
112113267Beinn Dearg North Top29/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12345. alda survey
112106113Easter Watery Knowe28/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12344. alda survey
112093114Wester Watery Knowe28/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12343. Summit alda survey. CT
to GT. Col not surveyed
112082943Meall Reamhar28/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12342. alda survey
112075721Creag na h-Iolaire28/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12341. alda survey. New Simm
1120619407 (New)Meall Reamhar North Top28/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
New Subsimm surveyed by alda
1120518705The Needle28/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Site visit to adjacent clifftop by RHW suggests 55m is
closer than 70m. Improved estimate but only supported by
contours on Hoy itself at similar height, hand held GPS and
climbing data (but this usually overstates). No mapping
evidence found.
112045429Hambledon Hill28/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12339. 450m relocation
following LIDAR analysis CC: Comment on relocation
1120319345Sron an Duin27/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Adding Maritime Area - South of Barra
1120217887Looe Island27/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
renamed by Alan Holmes
1120118768Ynys Ddu27/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
adding SIB status and tidal to align with SIB.v05
1120019222Horsea Island27/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
adding Maritime Area Hants & Dorset - Portsmouth & Wight
1119918939Eilean Mor27/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
adding Freshwater Maritime Area to align with SIB-Tables.v05
1119819230Porthmoina Island27/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Added to SIBs by Alan Holmes in his SIB-Tables.v05 CC:
revised drop from 1m LIDAR, DSM 36.7 but steepness of rock
doesn't support a decimal height
1119713985Hophills Nob26/07/2018GJApplied
(Agree=4)
Name on maps is Hophills Nob: Thanks to Ken Wood for
spotting this.
1119618674Cnoc Lomain North Top26/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12330. Name refers to a
feature 300m NE and is inappropriate - akin to naming a hill
Tumulus or Cairn
1119519374Coed Hafod-y-Llyn25/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Correcting Parent (Ma) error [Simon - no change to TS05]
111941644Uamh Bheag24/07/2018GJApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12316
1119312112Navvins21/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
7 summit candidate conundrum resolved by 5m contours on OSM.
No logs. Col review based on OSM too (subsequent site visit
confirms)
1119212116No Ness Head20/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12287. From OSM and
comparison with Holpur (and its 50m contour) I would make
this H53 col 17. However OSM looks 1 or 2m higher than
Geograph hereabouts (consistently), so heights reduced by
1m. No Ness refers to whole peninsula and farm. Summit is at
its very end, hence addition of Head to name
111912159Ffridd Cocyn20/07/2018CCApplied
(Agree=2)
update from LIDAR
1119019406 (New)Foel Tyddyn y Berllan20/07/2018CCApplied
(Agree=2)
New Tump discovered by Myrddyn Phillips. Data from LIDAR.
1118919405 (New)Ffridd Cocyn East Top20/07/2018CCApplied
(Agree=2)
New Tump discovered by Myrddyn Phillips. Data from LIDAR.
111887779Assycombe Hill20/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
LIDAR review of col. Prompted by The Fours
1118717505Sharpitor20/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
410 contour rings on OSM and Geograph. Interpolated with
reference to summit photo. I can't find 415 on a 1:10,000
map
1118617924North Molton Ridge20/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
col review from LIDAR prompted by The Fours. Complex summit
terrain, tumulus not at natural summit - LIDAR not used.
1118517492Challacombe Down20/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
col review prompted by The Fours
1118416535Lodge Moor20/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
col revision prompted by The Fours. Assessment not related
to spot height
1118316519Bowland Knotts20/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
col review prompted by The Fours
1118215937Sneer Hill20/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
summit & col revision prompted by The Fours
111817930Belles Knott20/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
col review prompted by The Fours
111807784Meldon Hill20/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
col LIDAR review prompted by The Fours. sHu demotion
111797780Hookney Tor20/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
col review prompted by The Fours
111787722Millstone Rigg20/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
col review prompted by The Fours
1117711518Carn Airigh Shomhairle18/07/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12274. N top has 75m contour
on OS Maps 30m N of GPS submission.
111767720Black Scar18/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
col tweak prompted by The Fours
111755615Hound Tor18/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
LIDAR review of col prompted by The Fours CC: DSM 414.3 (1m
data) but decimal dubious in terrain
1117412062Sae Breck17/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12268. ( )s justified after
site visit
1117315923Nettlehope Hill16/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
summit re evaluation prompted by The Fours
1117216092Whinfell Beacon16/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
col review prompted by The Fours
1117116537Waggonshaw Brow16/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Summit from NLS 1344.1-0.3ft = 409.6m. Prompted by The Fours
1117016368Hope Fell16/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
col review prompted by The Fours
1116916367Greenhow Hill Top16/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Col re-evaluation prompted by The Fours
11168162Sron Dha Mhurchaidh [Sron dha-Murchdi]15/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
OS consistent on name - spotted by alda. Retaining old SMC
name for search facilitation (MT deleted 1921)
11167672Meall an t-Snaim15/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
name tweak - spotted by alda
11166458Cac Carn Mor14/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
new subSimm proposed by alda. An average of Geograph and OSM
contours at col supports.
11165816Ciste Dhubh East Top14/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
name change from alda
111643186Ladhar Bheinn Far South Top14/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
name change from alda linked to previous CR
111636378Ladhar Bheinn South Top14/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
name change from alda linked to next CR
111624290Druim a' Ghoirtein Far West Top14/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
name change from alda to accommodate new subSimm identified
in previous CR
1116119404 (New)Druim a' Ghoirtein West Top14/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
new Subsimm identified and surveyed by alda. GR10 data to
follow. (CC) correcting Class code
1116010992Dun an Dubh-challa11/07/2018SEApplied
(Agree=3)
Hill name correction spotted by Darren Giddins
111593197Meall Dubh09/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12165. alda survey
11158760Meall Coire Lochain09/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12164. alda survey
11157759Meall na Teanga09/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12163. alda survey
1115612036Score Hill09/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12156 and ( )s. Site visit
111552634The Old Man of Coniston [Coniston Old Man]08/07/2018GJApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12131
111544922Ward of Clett08/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
( ) and logs
111532240Fan y Big05/07/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
Simm/Tump deletion following LIDAR analysis and survey by M
Phillips reported on the rhb group
111528622Cnoc Loch Kemp04/07/2018GGApplied
(Agree=3)
GR6 summit tweak
1115114614Bryn Gwyn02/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Catchment error spotted by Chris Watson. Deleting
Glaslyn, adding Gwyrfai
111507510Clogwynygarreg02/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Catchment error spotted by Chris Watson. Deleting Glaslyn,
adding Gwyrfai
111493878Horsehow Crags01/07/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
Col relocation from OS Maps prompted by The Fours. Can't
find source of old col GR8.
111482635Swirl How28/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12018. Height change
following G&J survey
1114713273Glencaird Hill [Balraggan]27/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12016. Summit name tweak and
relocation after visit by chrisbien, supportive log from
Dazingdale & summit Cr spot height of 1125.7ft on 1853 NLS
(at least 343m).
111463791Darling Fell27/06/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
Col tweak prompted by The Fours. OS Maps reading lower than
Geograph.
111453786Dawsonground Crags27/06/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
LIDAR analysis. Col tweak prompted by The Fours.
111443782Sourfoot Fell27/06/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
LIDAR analysis. Col tweak prompted by The Fours.
111433779Lang How27/06/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
OS Maps col tweak prompted by The Fours
111422484Burnbank Fell27/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
col re-evaluation prompted by The Fours
111413755Yew Bank27/06/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
OS Maps col tweak prompted by The Fours
111402495Fellbarrow - Mosser Fell27/06/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
LIDAR analysis. Tweak prompted by The Fours.
1113912078Head of Lambhoga24/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
OSM supports RHW's 2013 assertion that it is c P25. Tump
demotion
1113816497Hameldon23/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 11986. LIDAR analysis. Tweak
prompted by The Fours
1113716536Fox Low23/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 11985. LIDAR analysis.
Tweak prompted by The Fours
1113615951The Middle23/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 11984. LIDAR analysis.
Tweak prompted by The Fours
111357698Ether Knott23/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 11982. LIDAR analysis. Tweak
prompted by The Fours
111347901Knotts23/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 11981. LIDAR analysis.
Tweak prompted by The Fours
111337759Rock Hill23/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 11980. LIDAR analysis. Tweak
prompted by The Fours
111326381Meall Coire na Gaoithe'n Ear23/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 11979. New Simm following
alda survey
111312831Cringle Moor - Drake Howe21/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
tweak prompted by The Fours
1113019403 (New)Wether Lair21/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
New s4 identified by Myrddyn Phillips & Aled Williams in The
Fours
111292603Grayrigg Forest21/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
tweak prompted by The Fours
111282485Lingmoor Fell [Lingmoor Fell - Brown How]21/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
tweak prompted by The Fours
111272493Low Fell21/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
tweak prompted by The Fours
111266384Sgurr Coire nan Gobhar North Top18/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Name re-appraisal - linked to previous CR
111257876Sgurr nam Feadan18/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 11934. alda summit survey.
Name re-appraisal.
11124200Stob an Fhuarain18/06/2018DMApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 11923
1112311682Cats Craig17/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Tump deletion prompted by chrisbien's GPS report. Geograph
and OSM mapping conflict and the 25K col spot contradicts
its adjacent contours. 1971-75 10K supports col at 224.
Comment added.
11122324Mullach nan Coirean East Top16/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Reclassifying as Murdo after alda survey raised height to
>914.4. Missed this in 2017. Spotted by mae (still not a
Munro Top).
1112119402 (New)Creag Feusag West Top15/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
New subSimm surveyed by alda
111206549Cnoc na Moine15/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 11904. alda summit survey
111196238Sreang Glas a' Chuill15/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 11903. alda survey. Delete
Comment