Change Requests


Sign in if you wish to make any changes (editors only)

Click on Change no. for more details...

Change no.Hill no.Hill nameSectionReq. dateByStatusDescription
120895710Leacan Dubha West Top01B20/11/2019CCRequested
(Agree=2)
Name change proposed by alda. Current name incorrect as col
is lower.
120885166Coed Hyrddyn [Moel Tan y Coed]30C20/11/2019CCRequested
(Agree=2)
Alt name change. Moel Tan y Coed was an invented name that
does not appear on any map. Known to English speakers as
Velvet Hill which is shown on National Trust signs and OSM.
Credit to Myrddyn Phillips.
120875819Meall nam Maigheach North Top02A20/11/2019JimRequested
(Agree=3)
Simm promotion after alda s&c survey. GRUpdate done
separately.
120863664Aonach Eagach East Top03A19/11/2019CCRequested
(Agree=3)
alda name change
12085184Aonach Eagach West Top03A19/11/2019CCRequested
(Agree=3)
alda name change
120846964Cnoc na Tricriche19C19/11/2019CCRequested
(Agree=3)
OS name change, spotted by alda
120835448Newmarket Hill4219/11/2019CCRequested
(Agree=2)
Adding alt summit (a Dewey Notable) raised by RHW. No LIDAR.
No 200m contour for either hill on OS Maps.
12082211Beinn Maol Chaluim03B19/11/2019JimRevised
(Agree=2)
alda summit survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15895
120815872Beinn Maol Chaluim South Top03B19/11/2019JimRevised
(Agree=2)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15894
120806355Beinn a' Chapuill West Top10A19/11/2019JimRevised
(Agree=2)
alda s&c surveyChange linked to GR update ref 15893
12079722Beinn a' Chapuill10A19/11/2019JimRevised
(Agree=2)
alda summit survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15892
12078 (New)Ciste Dhubh South Top11A19/11/2019JimRequested
(Agree=3)
New sSim surveyed by alda
120776447An Cnapach11A19/11/2019JimRevised
(Agree=2)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15891
12076834Ciste Dhubh11A19/11/2019JimRevised
(Agree=2)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15890
12075855Am Bathach11A19/11/2019JimRevised
(Agree=2)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15889
120746453Am Bathach South Top11A19/11/2019JimRevised
(Agree=2)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15888
120736344Creag Chathalain09C19/11/2019JimRevised
(Agree=2)
alda summit survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15887
120724256Creag Liath09C19/11/2019JimRevised
(Agree=2)
alda summit survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15886
120715923Meallan Odhar04B19/11/2019JimRevised
(Agree=2)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15885
120705825Creagan na Corr02A19/11/2019JimRevised
(Agree=2)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15884
120696264Sith Mor09B19/11/2019JimRevised
(Agree=2)
Simm promotion following alda s&c survey. Change linked to
GR update ref 15883. Comment on col added from alda file.
120684213Carn Easgainn Mor09B19/11/2019JimRevised
(Agree=2)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15882
120676268Carn Mor09B19/11/2019JimRevised
(Agree=2)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15881
120666276Carn na Lair09B19/11/2019JimRevised
(Agree=2)
alda summit survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15696
12065373Leacann na Sguabaich04B19/11/2019JimRevised
(Agree=2)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15880
1206418235Rox Hill4118/11/2019JimRevised
(Agree=2)
Height reduction from LIDAR. Reservoir does not appear to
cover natural summit. Change linked to GR update ref 15866.
Marginal Tump given benefit of doubt (no LIDAR at col).
1206318821The Bak2213/11/2019JimRequested
(Agree=3)
Tump demotion on balance of conflicting evidence. Clear 27m
spot height on Geograph supported by 25m contour on OS_M but
this is contradicted by Topo (blown up 25K) which does have
a 30m contour. Evidence insufficient to uphold a discrepancy
(SIB v Tump).
1206210131Eilean Dubh16A12/11/2019JimRevised
(Agree=3)
Lengthy study. Evidence for P30 is marginal. 25K & Topo is
supportive of H30+. Google satellite image suggests water
passes through channel (perhaps only at high tide). Evidence
insufficient to uphold a discrepancy (SIB v Tump).
120614035Beinn Mhic-Mhonaidh East Top03C10/11/2019GGRequested
(Agree=3)
parent name change on current maps. Thanks to alda.
120606311Creag Bhalg09B09/11/2019CCRequested
(Agree=3)
Col height change suggested by alda. 438m spot looks like a
knoll or an error. No LIDAR. New Subhump.
120595891Stob Dubh South Top03C09/11/2019CCRequested
(Agree=3)
name change from alda
12058267Beinn Mhic-Mhonaidh03C09/11/2019CCRequested
(Agree=3)
Name change on current maps. Thanks to alda.
120574190Sherramore Forest09B09/11/2019CCRequested
(Agree=3)
Name change from alda, in keeping with other name changes in
the Monaliath. Sherramore Forest is the name of an area not
a hill. Col tweak from OS Maps.
1205615643Mynydd Pen-y-fan32C09/11/2019CCRevised
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 15813. LIDAR, see emails.
120555271Mynydd Bedwellte32C09/11/2019CCRequested
(Agree=2)
Adding LIDAR height. Possibly nearer 485.4m
120548457Knappy Park07B08/11/2019CCRevised
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 15816. LIDAR.
1205321192Mullaghanish Far North East Top [Garraneycarney]48C06/11/2019JimRequested
(Agree=2)
John FitzGerald summit survey for MV. Name changed
to exactly replicate MV. GRUpdate being done separately.
Drop rounded down 558.459
1205220597Mullaghanish NE Top [Mullach an Ois barr soir o thuaidh]48C06/11/2019JimRequested
(Agree=2)
John FitzGerald summit survey for MV. Name changed to
exactly replicate MV (and be consistent with 21192).
Unfortunately col not surveyed, therefore remains a
discrepancy (see Comment). Col height increased to reflect
discrepancy status (MV have P28). GRUpdate being done
separately.
1205114508Foel Lus30B04/11/2019DMRevised
(Agree=4)
Change linked to GR update ref 15809. Adding decimal height
from LIDAR analysis.
1205011721Cloghill21B04/11/2019DMRevised
(Agree=4)
Adding decimal height for summit from LIDAR
1204914281Dunsapie28A04/11/2019DMRevised
(Agree=4)
Adding decimal heights from LIDAR analysis of summit and col
120481474Beinn Tarsuinn20C31/10/2019DMRejected
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 15777. Adding decimal height
from LIDAR. Rejected after discovery of dodgy LIDAR data on
rocky Arran summits.
1204711319Cladh a' Bhearnaig19A28/10/2019JimRequested
(Agree=4)
Name change suggested by Ian Walter from mapping at
canmore.org.uk . Original name refers to burial ground N of
hill. Tweaks and corrections to col height from OS_M
12046 (New)Dalmeny Oil Depot28A25/10/2019CCRevised
(Agree=3)
New man-made Tump discovered by Chris Pearson, verified by
LIDAR. Summit of vegetated embankment on north side of
depot, NT 14695 77047 Garmin.
12045584Big Brae08B25/10/2019CCRevised
(Agree=4)
Change linked to GR update ref 15758. Relocation to tor
spotted at 940m on 1:10k suggested by alda/RHW as being more
likely to be Munro's intention. Emails and photos on file.
Col to the 942m top is 931.6m.
1204414300Calton Hill28A22/10/2019CCRequested
(Agree=3)
Increase in height from OS Maps and photos. Thanks to Chris
Pearson.
120438931Creag Liath12A18/10/2019DMRevised
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 15706. Adding decimal heights
for summit and col from LIDAR analysis.
120422271Mynydd Bwlch-y-Groes32A16/10/2019CCRevised
(Agree=3)
From alda. OS Maps suggests col 305-306m, supported by 999m
spot on old map at SN888386. 302m spot on 1:25k is not at
the col. Trig FB is 441.96. Submarilyn deletion.
120413147Creag an Dearg Lochain09B15/10/2019JimRequested
(Agree=3)
Serious omission from Inner Moray Firth Watershed. Can't be
in V009 and V013 and not be in W013.
120402913Crowborough4211/10/2019JimRejected
(Agree=1)
LIDAR study. Change linked to GR update ref 15673.
Subsequently rejected - decimal height unjustified in
complex summit situation.
12039584Big Brae08B10/10/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
OS_M indicates we are under estimating the drop - spotted by
alda.
12038550Stuc Gharbh Mhor (old GR)08B10/10/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
typo spotted by alda (see hill 545)
1203715715Mynydd y Drum SW Top32B09/10/2019GGApplied
(Agree=4)
class change, amending comment
120365381Liddington Castle3909/10/2019GGApplied
(Agree=4)
class change, amending comment
120355367Knoll Hill38B09/10/2019GGApplied
(Agree=4)
class change, amending comment
120342884Hensbarrow Beacon4009/10/2019GGApplied
(Agree=4)
class change, amending comment
120332666Lambrigg Fell (old GR)34D09/10/2019GGApplied
(Agree=4)
class change, amending comment
12032652Meall an Tarsaid (old GR)09B09/10/2019GGApplied
(Agree=4)
class change, amending comment
120312727Long Crag35A07/10/2019DMApplied
(Agree=4)
Summit LIDAR data probably unadjusted DSM - therefore not
using 686.4. Change linked to GR update ref 15672. No LIDAR
data at col but col re-appraised from OS_M. It's clear that
the 679 spot is not at the col. Geograph/OS_M closely
aligned on height.
120306377Fraoch Bheinn North Top10B07/10/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15671
12029748Fraoch Bheinn10B07/10/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
alda summit survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15670
120282981Creag an Lochain02B07/10/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15570
120275844Beinn a' Bhuic02B07/10/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15669
1202610644Meall Sanna North Top18A05/10/2019DMApplied
(Agree=4)
Change linked to GR update ref 15665 Adding GR8 for col
120254525Maol Odhar East Top18C05/10/2019DMApplied
(Agree=4)
Change linked to GR update ref 0 Adding GR8 for col
1202419504 (New)Hill of Skilmafilly21B02/10/2019CCApplied
(Agree=3)
New Tump in Aberdeenshire suggested by Chris Pearson
120235273Mynydd y Grug32C28/09/2019CCApplied
(Agree=3)
LIDAR col
120222297Mynydd Machen32C28/09/2019CCApplied
(Agree=3)
LIDAR update. Col on Bryn Road, summit at our GR10.
120215851Meall nan Tarmachan NE Top02B27/09/2019DMApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 15630. Adding decimal
heights for summit and col from Alan Dawson survey
1202018527West High Down4222/09/2019GGApplied
(Agree=2)
adding LIDAR data CC: correcting typo in col GR, GG:
correcting col GR
120195229Banc y Graig31C14/09/2019CCApplied
(Agree=2)
Revision to col height suggested by Myrddyn Phillips. Hump
deletion. OS Maps 5m contours col 309-310, no systematic
error vs. Geograph. 307m spot height at SN 69521 47114 on
1:10k is not at the col.
1201818269Combe Close4114/09/2019SEApplied
(Agree=4)
Name correction spotted by Bob Jones
120175266Long Hill32A13/09/2019CCApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 15537. LIDAR. Col appears to
be in a cutting.
120165632Brownber Head35A10/09/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Not in Tees Bay Watershed
1201516458Raisby Hill35A10/09/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Minor height tweak - quarry has extended 105m E. 182 spot
positions are no more. Change linked to GR update ref 15494
120146977Cruach nam Miseag Far West Top19C08/09/2019CCApplied
(Agree=2)
Name change to resolve conflict with 6973
1201307/09/2019GGApplied
(Agree=4)
Add 15 missing comments for Unclassified hills
120123265Faire nam Fiadh14B06/09/2019DMApplied
(Agree=2)
Adding values from LIDAR analysis
1201116468Lily Hill35A05/09/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Summit & col heights from LIDAR. Change linked to GR update
ref 15461
12010NB412106Stac a' Chomhraig24A03/09/2019JimRejected
(Agree=1)
Hebridean Stack. 29m on 25K and c 31m on OS_M. Good
candidate just rejected
120099828Hill of Lieurary16C03/09/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Relocating col. OS_M & NLS confirm we have the col at the
outlet of Loch Calder.
1200817665Higher Knowle Wood4003/09/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Name change suggested by RHW. Reserve called Higher Knowle
Wood and OS is supportive too. Change linked to GR update
ref 15436
1200717599Lobhill4003/09/2019JimRejected
(Agree=0)
Change linked to GR update ref 15450
1200617764Trekelland Hill4003/09/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Height change. GPSGR10 from RHW, 50K and OS_M all suggest
summit is W of the 25K spot height and LIDAR confirms this.
LIDAR at complicated col too. Change linked to GR update ref
15446.
1200517972Haydon Hill4002/09/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
LIDAR check following GPSGR10 submission. No LIDAR at col,
therefore retaining P29. Change linked to GR update ref
15432
1200419472Mew Stone4001/09/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
new SIB in v12 (class change only)
1200318759The Brisons4001/09/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
new SIB in v12 (class change only)
1200219503 (New)Stac a' Phris24A31/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
New seastack off Lewis spotted by Dave McGimpsey
1200119502 (New)Harnham Water Meadows4131/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
new SIB in v12
1200019501 (New)Wells Salt Marshes - West3931/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
new SIB in v12
1199919500 (New)Wells Salt Marshes - East3931/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
new SIB in v12
1199819499 (New)Ramsey Salt Marsh3931/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
new SIB in v12
1199719498 (New)Lodge Marsh3931/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
new SIB in v12
1199619497 (New)Warham Salt Marshes3931/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
new SIB in v12
1199518747Zacry's Island North4031/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
new SIB in v12 (class change only)
1199418746Zacry's Island South4031/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
new SIB in v12 (class change only)
1199318748Pendarves Island4031/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
new SIB in v12 (class change only)
1199219230Porthmoina Island4031/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
SIB deletion in v12 - considered too vertical
1199115568Mew Stone31C31/08/2019JimRejected
(Agree=1)
GG: wrong hill
1199012091The Greing2231/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
new SIB in v12 (class change only)
1198910116An Innis16C31/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
SIB deletion in v12 - considered too vertical
119884980Arnamuil [Arnamul]24D31/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
new SIB in v12
11987569Creag an Leth-choin North Top08A29/08/2019CCApplied
(Agree=3)
Changing col height based on OS Maps and alda estimate of
8-9m on visit
11986187Pap of Glencoe03A29/08/2019DMApplied
(Agree=2)
Adding decimal values for summit and col and GR8 for col
from alda survey following LIDAR analysis.
Feature/Observation/Survey to update separately. LIDAR has
chopped off rock in DTM.
119853185An Eag10B29/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15429
119846288Carn nan Grainnseag09B29/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Re-naming from 25K map - suggested by alda
11983969Stuc a' Choire Dhuibh Bhig13A29/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15428
11982958Stob a' Choire Liath Mhor [Stob a' Coire Liath Mhor] [1933: Bidean Toll a' Mhuic]13A29/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15427
11981953Liathach - Spidean a' Choire Leith13A29/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
alda summit survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15426
119803676Mullach an Rathain Far East Top13A29/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
alda survey processing tweak
1197919408Mullach an Rathain East Top13A29/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
survey processing variation. Change linked to GR update ref
15423. Delete Comment
119784279An t-Sail10B29/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15422
1197719496 (New)Sgurr nan Coireachan South Top10B29/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
New subsimm surveyed by alda. GR10 to be added.
11976736Sgurr nan Coireachan10B29/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
alda s&c survey on consecutive days. Change linked to GR
update ref 15420
119756379Garbh Chioch Bheag East Top10B29/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15418
11974734Garbh Chioch Bheag10B29/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15417
11973732Garbh Chioch Mhor10B29/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15416
1197219495 (New)Craig Backastain10B29/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
New subsimm surveyed by alda. Name on OS_M & NLS. GR10 to be
added.
11971730Sgurr na Ciche10B29/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
alda summit survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15415
119704273Druim a' Ghoirtein10B29/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15414
119694290Druim a' Ghoirtein Far West Top10B29/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15412
1196816442Burdon Moor35A27/08/2019JimRejected
(Agree=0)
Change linked to GR update ref 15411
119677467Ellson Fell South Top28B27/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Not in Tweed catchment - only in Esk
1196620551Sceilg Mhichil [Great Skellig]50A27/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
deleting a name and adding an h which now appears on
MountainViews
1196517430Brentwood Park3914/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
GR10 from Aye Jimmy confirms 2014 RHW submission. OS_M
indicates 120m at this position (outwith trees and is not
reading high). Change linked to GR update ref 15364. Photo
suggests major earthworks associated with ski slope
unlikely. Summit tweaked to LIDAR high point on the ski
slope. Re-named after dry ski slope.
119644399Slioch Far South Top14A11/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Renaming to facilitate previous CR
1196319494 (New)Slioch South Top14A11/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
New subsimm surveyed by alda [garmin NH 00757 68512/rock by
cairn/190808/Leica RX1250]
119624043Sgurr Finniosgaig [Sgurr Finnisg-aig]04A11/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Consistent naming on 25K & 50K - spotted by alda
1196111300Ganavan Hill19A11/08/2019CCApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 15352. LIDAR. Original col
36.0m
11960659Creag Meagaidh East Top09C11/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=4)
OS_M indicates drop under stated
119594201Carn Creagach09B10/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=4)
Name change proposed by alda (based on nearby burn)
119587873Carn Odhar Beag09B10/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=4)
Name change proposed by alda
119577874Carn Fionnach09B10/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=4)
Name change proposed by alda (based on nearby burn)
119561016Glas Mheall Liath14A07/08/2019DMRejected
(Agree=0)
Change linked to GR update ref 0
11955324Mullach nan Coirean East Top04A05/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
SMC have announced Munro Top status.
11954312An Gearanach04A05/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
alda summit re-survey with cairn dismantled. De-twinned.
Col height tweak from 2014 survey. Change linked to GR
update ref 15328.
11953313Stob Coire a' Chairn04A05/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
alda summit re-survey with cairn dismantled. De-twinned. Col
height tweak from 2014 survey. Change linked to GR update
ref 15327
11952675Beinn Teallach09C05/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
alda s&c survey. Summit survey replicates 2009 result.
Change linked to GR update ref 0. Col height rounded down to
avoid drop discrepancy. (Survey details updating separately
- see GRUpdate)
11951666Beinn a' Chaorainn North Top09C05/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15325
11950663Beinn a' Chaorainn09C05/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
alda summit survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15324
11949665Beinn a' Chaorainn South Top09C05/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15323
119486992Beinn Capuill19C04/08/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Adding Ardlamont Point to Fife Ness watershed.
119477564Clawdd Mawr30E28/07/2019GJApplied
(Agree=4)
Change linked to GR update ref 15313
11946823Beinn Fhada11A26/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda summit survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15275
1194513371Birkhill27A25/07/2019CCApplied
(Agree=3)
Col relocation following discovery of Broken Cross Muir
1194419493 (New)Broken Cross Muir27A25/07/2019CCApplied
(Agree=3)
New Tump on landscaped opencast workings proposed by Colin
Crawford. Summit taken from 1:10k, location and height in
doubt. Col swap with 13371 Birkhill.
1194319439Hoo Island4224/07/2019CCApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 15257. Revising height to
LIDAR value; only LAZ (unprocessed DSM) data available for
2018 post landscaping state.
119423214Meall a' Bhealaich11A23/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15256.
Rounding down summit height to avoid drop discrepancy.
11941840Meall an Fhuarain Mhoir11A23/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15158. Name
rationalisation following email discussion.
11940848Ceum na h-Aon-choise South Top11A23/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15203. Name
change to fit topographic hierarchy following surveys.
119396448Sgurr a' Choire Ghairbh11A23/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15159.
Rounding down col height to avoid drop discrepancy.
119383209Faradh Nighean Fhearchair11A23/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15160
11937299Stob an Chul-Choire [Stob an Cul Choire]04A22/07/2019CCApplied
(Agree=3)
OS name change spotted by alda. [] in Munro's Tables and old
LR
119364296Meall Tarsuinn10C22/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15254
11935765Meall Coire nan Saobhaidh10C22/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15253
11934764Meall na h-Eilde10C22/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda summit survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15252.
col tweak from OS_M/Geograph
119334291Meall an Tagraidh [Meall an t-Sagairt]10C22/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15251
119326405Meall na h-Eilde West Top10C22/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15250
119313979Beinn an t-Sithein [Beinn an t-Sidhein]01D22/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15110 CC:
removing alt name not on any map. Sidhein is on old LRs.
1193037Beinn a' Chroin West Top01C21/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15248
119292925Beinn a' Chroin01C21/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda col re-survey.
119285727Twistin Hill01C21/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15247
119275730Sron Gharbh01C21/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15246
119261830Broad Law28B21/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda summit survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15245
119251864Great Knock28B21/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Subsimm demotion following alda survey of summit and col.
Change linked to GR update ref 15244
119244388Sgurr na Bana-Mhoraire13B20/07/2019CCApplied
(Agree=3)
OS name change on online mapping. Hyphen is linguistically
correct.
1192319317Sgurr Cadha na Beucaich16B10/07/2019DMApplied
(Agree=4)
Change linked to GR update ref 15198. Adding GR8 for col
1192217318Henley Hill3910/07/2019CCApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 15193. Increasing height
based on old map. Mound appears to overlie natural summit.
1192117340Little Solsbury Hill3910/07/2019DMApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 15192. Adding decimal height
from LIDAR data
1192019492 (New)Ceum na h-Aon-choise11A09/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=4)
New Subsimm proposed by Alan Duval (site visit) but actually
surveyed by alda in 2017 awaiting announcement. The 891m
spot height is erroneous. (13082017/Garmin NG 99549
20118/outcrop/Leica RX1250/SummitX[supported by K&AD
GR10]).
1191916792Wincobank Hill3605/07/2019CCApplied
(Agree=3)
Name change proposed by M Phillips from literature & notice
board. Old 6in map labels the NE spur as Wincobank Hill Top.
1191819491 (New)Stac a' Chuirn East Top01D05/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
New Subsimm surveyed by alda (Garmin NN 19465
18258.knoll.Leica RX1250)
1191717478Upper Hill3905/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
LIDAR study indicates numerous potential summit locations
with a height greater than 58.5m CC: updated GPS database,
DTM summit is 59.0m.
11916NM861927Sgurr nam Meirleach South Top10D05/07/2019CCRejected
(Agree=1)
alda s&c survey of potential Simm
119154489Meall Dearg16F05/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15092
119141207Cul Beag16F05/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda summit survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15091
119131212Stac Pollaidh16F05/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Summit survey concurs. Change linked to GR
update ref 15090
119124012Meall Buidhe02B05/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15089
11911169Beinn Odhar02B05/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda summit survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15088
119104059Gualann Sheileach05A05/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda summit survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15087
11909404Creag a' Mhadaidh05A05/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15086
119081272Beinn Bhreac17B05/07/2019JimRejected
(Agree=1)
alda summit survey with 240m relocation. Change linked to GR
update ref 15083. CR redundant as surveyed height is 448.0m.
CC: added Comment to GR Update
119074793Stockval17B05/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15082
119064493The Storr East Top17A05/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15081 CC:
correcting drop
119051218The Storr17A05/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda summit survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15080.
CC: rounding drop
119046843Old Man of Storr17A05/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
col survey by alda CC: adding GR8
119031242Sgurr Thearlaich17B05/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15079
119021239Sgurr Alasdair17B05/07/2019JimRejected
(Agree=1)
CR not required - please Reject. Change linked to GR update
ref 15078 CC: added Comment to GR update
119011249Sgurr Sgumain17B05/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15077
119006986The Saddle19C05/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15076
118994532Beinn Reithe19C05/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15075
11898792Glas-charn10D05/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15074
1189719240Glas-charn SE Top10D05/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Tweaking survey result (rounding). Change linked to GR
update ref 15073
118964312Sgurr Mor10D05/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15072
118954302Sgurr Breac10D05/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda summit survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15071
1189419331Sgurr Breac East Top10D05/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Adding col GR8 from alda survey. Change linked to GR update
ref 15070
118933200Sgurr na h-Aide10D05/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15068
11892779Bidein a' Chabair10D04/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda summit survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15067
118914300Sgurr nam Meirleach10D04/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15066
11890NM465667Beinn na h-Imeilte East Top18A04/07/2019CCRejected
(Agree=1)
Tump candidate rejected by alda survey
11889786Druim Fada10D04/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda col survey CC: adding col GR8
118884304Druim Gleann Laoigh10D04/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15065
118874299Meall a' Phubuill East Top10D04/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15064
11886784Meall a' Phubuill10D04/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda summit survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15063
11885798Cruach Dhubh an Ruidhe Fearna10D04/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15062
118844823Beinn na h-Imeilte18A04/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15061
118831345Meall an Tarmachain18A04/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15060
118827773Quainton Hill3904/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Natural summit is c 1m lower than trig base on reservoir.
Flush bracket is 187.14m. Change linked to GR update ref
15047. Site visit by Jim (without Abney but useful v long
distance horizons providing good perspective). Geograph
contour suggests 185m.
1188119130Milbury Heath3904/07/2019GJRejected
(Agree=0)
Change linked to GR update ref 15051
11880908Sgurr a' Choire-rainich12A01/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Sub Marilyn demotion. alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR
update ref 15041
11879NG911466Carn Cadha an Eididh South Top13B01/07/2019JimRejected
(Agree=2)
alda s&c survey P19.92 CC: correcting summit height and
adding col GR
118786537Carn Gorm East Top12A01/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
New name proposed by alda. alda s&c survey. Change linked to
GR update ref 15037
118774345Creag Sgiathan12A01/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15036
118766648Torr na h-Iolaire Far South Top13B01/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15035
118756636Meall an Daimh13B01/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15034
11874988An Ruadh-Stac13B01/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda summit survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15033
118737857Carn Cadha an Eididh13B01/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
sub Simm demotion. alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR
update ref 15032
1187219490 (New)Cuil Ghlas03C01/07/2019CCApplied
(Agree=3)
new Subdodd proposed by alda
118714393Carn Dearg13B01/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda summit survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15031
11870990Sgurr a' Chaorachain13B01/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda col survey CC: rounding drop, add comment
118694395Sgurr a' Chaorachain Far North Top13B01/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15030
1186881Beinn Luibhean01D01/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15029
1186768Beinn Ime01D01/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda summit survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15028
11866NN262085Beinn Ime East Top01D01/07/2019JimRejected
(Agree=2)
alda s&c survey P17.2
1186578Beinn Chorranach01D01/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Submarilyn demotion. alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR
update ref 15027
11864123Meall Buidhe02A01/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda col survey
11863133Sron a' Choire Chnapanaich [Sron a' Choire Chnapanich]02A01/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15026. Name
swap tweak to reflect current OS 50K & 25K
11862922Beinn Raimh12A01/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda summit survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15025
118611684Wedder Hill [Blackside]27A01/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Sub Marilyn summit survey by alda who proposes name change
to better reflect OS mapping. Change linked to GR update ref
15024
11860903Sgurr a' Mhuilinn12A01/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda summit survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15023
118593228Sgurr a' Ghlas Leathaid12A01/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15022
118584349Creag Ghlas12A01/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15021
11857909Meallan nan Uan12A01/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15020
118566536Meallan nan Uan East Top12A01/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15019
118554343Creag Ruadh12A01/07/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 15018
1185418711Slender Drong2227/06/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Photo from Oris Field, presented by Charles Everett,
indicates that this stack is 79.6% as high as the 41m Main
Drong which is 80m SW of it.
1185318710Main Drong2227/06/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Height reduction. Tiny 40m contour on OS_M. Photo from Oris
Field, presented by Charles Everett, indicates that this
stack is only 25.6% higher than Slender Drong (SD) which is
80m NE of it.
1185218711Slender Drong2226/06/2019JimRejected
(Agree=1)
Photo from Oris Field, presented by Charles Everett,
indicates that this stack is 79.6% as high as the 60m Main
Drong which is 80m SW of it.
1185119433Raga Wick Far North Stack2225/06/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Height increase to align with 35m OS_M contour. Adding the
word stack to name.
11850HU306671Baa Geo Stack2224/06/2019JimRejected
(Agree=2)
Possible new Shetland Tump, data from OS_M supported by
photographic evidence. Close contender.
1184918743Tame Holm2224/06/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Tump demotion from photographic evidence following Jon Glew
et al visit. We believe OS_M contours reflect reality
whereas the 30m contour on 10K & 25K is an aberration.
1184821110Knocknaheeny48C23/06/2019SEApplied
(Agree=2)
Replaced by Rathmacullig as Cork City top following changes
to county boundary on 31 May 2019.
1184721451 (New)Rathmacullig52B23/06/2019SEApplied
(Agree=2)
New Cork City county top following changes to county
boundary on 31 May 2019. With thanks to Gerry Bowes for the
research. (GarminGR10: W 68287 66179 175 ground by telegraph
pole)
1184619419Sweinn Geo North Stack2323/06/2019CCApplied
(Agree=3)
Changing to Chris P's name as per his TF posting - Stack got
missed off
1184519418Sweinn Geo Far North Stack2323/06/2019CCApplied
(Agree=3)
Changing to Chris P's name as per his TF posting - Stack got
missed off
11844HU382458Black Hill North Top2222/06/2019CCRejected
(Agree=1)
Possible Tump in Shetlands identifed by Rob Woodall.
Photogrammetry on OS Maps c.2m lower
1184319489 (New)Oris Field2221/06/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
New Tump replacing 18708 Hu Field. Situation on ground
confirmed by Rob Woodall. OS_M fully supportive. Height from
1878 6 inch map. This col tweaked in light of OS_M (was
HU275762/38 - Geograph/OS_M in close height agreement)
1184218708Hu Field2221/06/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Tump summit relocated to Oris Field. See next CR. Jim to
check number in Comments is correct after application
1184112150Outer Stack2221/06/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Height increase. Rob Woodall hand levelling from summit to
Scordar suggests it is 4m lower. Scordar has a 44m spot
height.
1184019488 (New)Barlcudda2220/06/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
New Shetland Stack Tump first identified by Jon Glew, height
assesments from David Purchase & Rob Woodall (from Gruney
using hand level and multiples of eye height)
118394497Sgurr nan Each17B20/06/2019CCApplied
(Agree=3)
Col tweak. c638 on OS Maps but prefer 2087' spot on 1965
1:10560 map.
1183819487 (New)Sgurr nan Each West Top17B20/06/2019CCApplied
(Agree=3)
New Subsimm N of Blabheinn identified from 1965 1:10560 map.
Summit 2323', col below 2250' (686m) but have conservatively
taken 688m as more compatible with Geo/OS Maps.
118375521Westerhope Hill Heads3317/06/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Name change and acceptance of LIDAR evidence brought to our
attention by Anthony Foster. Change linked to GR update ref
14850. See emails
118366354Sgurr a' Bhac Chaolais East Top10A17/06/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 14614
11835713Buidhe Bheinn10A17/06/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
alda col survey
11834708Creag nan Damh10A17/06/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
alda summit survey. Change linked to GR update ref 14848
118334257Sgurr a' Chuilinn10A17/06/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 14847
1183219486 (New)Baton Bing28A14/06/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New Tump Bing proposed by Colin Crawford. Vegetation level
appears high. Heights directly from OS_M.
1183119485 (New)The Heog2213/06/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
New Shetland Tump. Seven clear 5m contours on OS_M. Colin
Crawford's altimeter gave P36 (1 way in windy conditions).
Garmin HU 35013 81987 (81 no feature). OS_M heights 82/50.
56m sh is a hill between 2 cols. Geograph is c 2.5m higher
therefore averaging at 51/83.
11830755Slat Bheinn10B10/06/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 14797
118294275Druim Chosaidh10B10/06/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 14796
118283195Sgurr Airigh na Bheinne10B10/06/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 14795
118277896Sgurr Airigh na Bheinne East Top10B10/06/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 14794
1182619411Meall a' Charra11A10/06/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 14786
11825683Gleouraich10A10/06/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda col survey
1182412015Virda Stane Hill2209/06/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Major relocation & renaming. Initially spotted on OS_M
before site visit. Change linked to GR update ref 14780.
Geograph confirms. Will ask RHW to delete his log
11823435The Cairnwell06B08/06/2019DMRejected
(Agree=2)
raised in error
1182217908Rat Island4004/06/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
LIDAR confirming summit & col position and height. Change
linked to GR update ref 14678
1182111952Muckle Hallitie2204/06/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Wrong name. See previous CR
1182012094Little Hallitie2204/06/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Loss of SIB status following site visit on 16 June 2019 by A
Holmes/Jim and 10 others. Too vertical. Wrong name. Muckle
Hallitie is part of Mainland
1181919484 (New)Hyter2204/06/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
New Shetland Stack (30m contour on OS_M Name on Geograph).
**SIMON** mapping location HU 3748 9738
118187078Muskna Field2202/06/2019JimApplied
(Agree=4)
Drop re-evaluation after prompt by Charles Everett
118171240Sgurr Dearg - Inaccessible Pinnacle17B02/06/2019DMApplied
(Agree=2)
Adding GR10 for col. Col is very sharply defined. CC:
changing to alda's RX1250 GR (he gave a GR10 for this)
1181610285Leathad Chrithinn NE Top17B31/05/2019CCApplied
(Agree=3)
612ft spot height on 1965 1:10560 map. Summit 732ft, drop
36.5m. Leathad Chrithinn to SW also spotted 1m higher on old
map.
1181519084Eilean Chirceboist24C31/05/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
OS_M suggests ground 2.5km SE is c 22m. This is a sand dune
area but preferred over recent GR10 reports. Change linked
to GR update ref 0. (CC) Vegetated in photos e.g.
https://www.geograph.org.uk/photo/2644175
1181412771Ceann Uachdarach (Bhalaigh)24C31/05/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
RHW GR10 report. Change linked to GR update ref 14651.
Position closer to 50K spot. OS_M supportive of height
increase
118136375Sgurr a' Choire-bheithe East Top10B31/05/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
alda s&c survey - details to follow to be contained in
GRUpdate. Subsequently adding col GR8.
118125919Meall an t-Slugain04B30/05/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
4 contours on OS_M - looks closer than we thought. Spotted
by alda.
118114315Beinn Bhuidhe [Beinn Bhuide]11A30/05/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda col survey CC: amending col height to give correct drop
(summit 702.12, col 577.55)
11810853Sgurr an Airgid11A30/05/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda summit survey. Change linked to GR update ref 14628
118096450Sgurr na Seamraig11A30/05/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Subsimm deletion. alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR
update ref 14627
118081247Bruach na Frithe17B30/05/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda summit survey. Change linked to GR update ref 14626
118073297An Caisteal17B30/05/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda col survey (drop rounded up as surveyed height is
763.48)
118063296Bidein Druim nan Ramh17B30/05/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda survey of col. Change linked to GR update ref 0 (drop
rounded up - survey 760.49m) CC: amending comment
118054267Beinn Aoidhdailean10A29/05/2019CCApplied
(Agree=3)
Removing comment, not needed post survey. Database Notes
entry being removed.
1180419408Mullach an Rathain East Top13A28/05/2019CCApplied
(Agree=3)
adding Comment
118031255Bla Bheinn [Blabheinn] [Blaven]17B28/05/2019CCApplied
(Agree=2)
Spot height in col area found by Joe Nuttall. Small ring
contours are all 70m on Topo, doubtless contour at NG 4950
2428 on OS Maps is too. Flat boggy area in Geograph photo.
118023035Carn Dearg05A28/05/2019CCApplied
(Agree=2)
Spot height at col supported by OS Maps. Thanks to Joe
Nuttall.
118013201Sgurr a' Choire Riabhaich10D28/05/2019CCApplied
(Agree=2)
Revised col height from OS Maps suggested by Joe Nuttall.
Geograph 810m spot looks spurious, photo shows a definite
dip and no suggestion of a pronounced bump.
118007885Bidein Druim nan Ramh North Top17B28/05/2019CCApplied
(Agree=3)
alda survey of summit and col
117993139Bac nam Fuaran09B27/05/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 14617
117983129Geal Charn09B27/05/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 14616
117976236Carn an Aonaich Odhair09B27/05/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 14615
11796632Corrieyairack Hill09B27/05/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 14612
117953131Gairbeinn North Top09B27/05/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 14611
11794631Gairbeinn09B27/05/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
alda summit survey. Change linked to GR update ref 14610
117936326Meallan Odhar09B27/05/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Dodd shrunk to a 4. alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR
update ref 14609
117924189Creag a' Chail09B27/05/2019JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 14608. Drop
100.001
117916244Poll-gormack Hill East Top09B27/05/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 14607
117903152Poll-gormack Hill09B27/05/2019JimApplied
(Agree=2)
alda s&c survey. Change linked to GR update ref 14606