Change Requests


Sign in if you wish to make any changes (editors only)

Click on Change no. for more details...

Change no.Hill no.Hill nameReq. dateByStatusDescription
11254SJ506819Runcorn Hill19/08/2018GGRejected
(Agree=1)
new hill suggested by Derek Kettlewell, rejected on LIDAR
data analysis
1125315971Sappers' Pike17/08/2018JimRequested
(Agree=2)
Catchment inherent contradiction. Can't be in Minor Rivers
only and Tyne (Newcastle).
1125215979Mount Gilbert17/08/2018JimRevised
(Agree=2)
Catchment inherent contradiction. Can't be in Minor
Rivers only and Tyne (Newcastle).
1125115950Darden Rigg17/08/2018JimRequested
(Agree=2)
Catchment inherent contradiction. Can't be in Minor
Rivers only and Coquetdale.
1125016048Beacon Hill17/08/2018JimRequested
(Agree=2)
Catchment inherent contradiction. Can't be in Minor
Rivers only and Coquetdale.
1124916009Coldrife Hill17/08/2018JimRequested
(Agree=2)
Catchment inherent contradiction. Can't be in Minor
Rivers only and Coquetdale.
112482315Tosson Hill17/08/2018JimRequested
(Agree=2)
Catchment inherent contradiction. Can't be in Minor Rivers
only and Coquetdale.
11247SW929806Pentire Head15/08/2018DMRejected
(Agree=4)
new hill suggested by Chris Pearson, rejected on LIDAR
analysis
11246SW932811The Rumps15/08/2018GGRejected
(Agree=3)
new hill suggested by David Gradwell, rejected on LIDAR data
analysis
112452337High Pike (Caldbeck)10/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
G&J col survey
112442343Miller Moss [Little Lingy Hill]10/08/2018GJApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12474
112432454Illgill Head10/08/2018GJApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12473
1124217013Brynspeard Hill10/08/2018SEApplied
(Agree=4)
Hill name change spotted by Paul Grantham (Brynspard on old
LR161 and all older maps)
1124119230Porthmoina Island05/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=4)
col data from Alan Holmes review
112402178Great Rhos02/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Col swap with 2182 Pegwn Mawr following careful study and
survey by Myrddyn Phillips
112392182Pegwn Mawr02/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Col swap with 2178 Great Rhos following careful study and
survey by Myrddyn Phillips
1123819409 (New)The Sugarloaf02/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
IoM seastack. LIDAR data from Department of Infrastucture,
Douglas - procured by the efforts of Darren Giddins
1123719283North Gaulton Castle01/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
site visit to adjacent cliffs by RHW - comparison with
Mainland contours and hand held GPS suggest 35m. No mapping
evidence found
112366684Cnoc a' Bhaid-rallaich West Top01/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12374. alda survey
11235954Liathach - Mullach an Rathain01/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12373. alda survey. col swap
11234967Am Fasarinen01/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12372. alda survey. col swap
(see next CR)
1123319408 (New)Mullach an Rathain East Top01/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
alda survey of new Subsimm
112323676Mullach an Rathain Far East Top01/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12371. alda survey. Name
change to accommodate next CR
1123118784Am Bodach01/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New parent (Ma)
1123010021Dunan Beag01/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New parent (Ma)
1122918771Geodha Glas Head01/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New parent (Ma)
112284727Dunan Mor01/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New parent (Ma)
112279633Sithean na h-Iolaireich01/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New parent (Ma)
112269855Cnoc Loch na Seamraig01/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New parent (Ma)
1122518785Stac Geodha Cul an Fhraochaidh01/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New parent (Ma)
112241121Cnoc a' Ghiubhais01/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New parent (Ma)
112239712Cnoc an t-Socaich Ghlais01/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New parent (Ma)
112229635Maovally More01/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New parent (Ma)
112219719Cnoc a' Gheodha Ruaidh01/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New parent (Ma)
112206774Cnoc na Glaic Tarsuinn01/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New parent (Ma)
112191117Beinn Dearg01/08/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12370. Jon Metcalfe survey.
New Marilyn
112184927Old Man of Hoy30/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Col height: OSM and Geograph (both with 5m contours)
indicate between 15 and 20m. Site visit by RichardM & RHW
propose 21/22m from altimeter readings. Adding 4m as
sensible compromise.
112174388Sgurr na Bana Mhoraire29/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12361. alda survey. alda
reports - Map has 588m at col indicating drop of 99m. This
looks in the right place on the map but there is lower
ground to the south and east near a small unmapped lochan
where the ridge line flattens out.
112166632Spidean Toll nam Biast29/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12360
112153252Creagan Dubh Toll nam Biast29/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12359. alda survey
112143268Creag a' Choire Ghranda29/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12348. alda survey. Retiral
of old South Top name
112134426Carn Loch nan Eilean [Leac an Tuadh]29/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12347. alda summit survey.
Summit renamed by OS - spotted by alda
112126714Beinn Dearg West Top29/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12346. alda survey
112113267Beinn Dearg North Top29/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12345. alda survey
112106113Easter Watery Knowe28/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12344. alda survey
112093114Wester Watery Knowe28/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12343. Summit alda survey. CT
to GT. Col not surveyed
112082943Meall Reamhar28/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12342. alda survey
112075721Creag na h-Iolaire28/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12341. alda survey. New Simm
1120619407 (New)Meall Reamhar North Top28/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
New Subsimm surveyed by alda
1120518705The Needle28/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Site visit to adjacent clifftop by RHW suggests 55m is
closer than 70m. Improved estimate but only supported by
contours on Hoy itself at similar height, hand held GPS and
climbing data (but this usually overstates). No mapping
evidence found.
112045429Hambledon Hill28/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12339. 450m relocation
following LIDAR analysis CC: Comment on relocation
1120319345Sron an Duin27/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Adding Maritime Area - South of Barra
1120217887Looe Island27/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
renamed by Alan Holmes
1120118768Ynys Ddu27/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
adding SIB status and tidal to align with SIB.v05
1120019222Horsea Island27/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
adding Maritime Area Hants & Dorset - Portsmouth & Wight
1119918939Eilean Mor27/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
adding Freshwater Maritime Area to align with SIB-Tables.v05
1119819230Porthmoina Island27/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Added to SIBs by Alan Holmes in his SIB-Tables.v05 CC:
revised drop from 1m LIDAR, DSM 36.7 but steepness of rock
doesn't support a decimal height
1119713985Hophills Nob26/07/2018GJApplied
(Agree=4)
Name on maps is Hophills Nob: Thanks to Ken Wood for
spotting this.
1119618674Cnoc Lomain North Top26/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12330. Name refers to a
feature 300m NE and is inappropriate - akin to naming a hill
Tumulus or Cairn
1119519374Coed Hafod-y-Llyn25/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Correcting Parent (Ma) error [Simon - no change to TS05]
111941644Uamh Bheag24/07/2018GJApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12316
1119312112Navvins21/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
7 summit candidate conundrum resolved by 5m contours on OSM.
No logs. Col review based on OSM too (subsequent site visit
confirms)
1119212116No Ness Head20/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12287. From OSM and
comparison with Holpur (and its 50m contour) I would make
this H53 col 17. However OSM looks 1 or 2m higher than
Geograph hereabouts (consistently), so heights reduced by
1m. No Ness refers to whole peninsula and farm. Summit is at
its very end, hence addition of Head to name
111912159Ffridd Cocyn20/07/2018CCApplied
(Agree=2)
update from LIDAR
1119019406 (New)Foel Tyddyn y Berllan20/07/2018CCApplied
(Agree=2)
New Tump discovered by Myrddyn Phillips. Data from LIDAR.
1118919405 (New)Ffridd Cocyn East Top20/07/2018CCApplied
(Agree=2)
New Tump discovered by Myrddyn Phillips. Data from LIDAR.
111887779Assycombe Hill20/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
LIDAR review of col. Prompted by The Fours
1118717505Sharpitor20/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
410 contour rings on OSM and Geograph. Interpolated with
reference to summit photo. I can't find 415 on a 1:10,000
map
1118617924North Molton Ridge20/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
col review from LIDAR prompted by The Fours. Complex summit
terrain, tumulus not at natural summit - LIDAR not used.
1118517492Challacombe Down20/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
col review prompted by The Fours
1118416535Lodge Moor20/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
col revision prompted by The Fours. Assessment not related
to spot height
1118316519Bowland Knotts20/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
col review prompted by The Fours
1118215937Sneer Hill20/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
summit & col revision prompted by The Fours
111817930Belles Knott20/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
col review prompted by The Fours
111807784Meldon Hill20/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
col LIDAR review prompted by The Fours. sHu demotion
111797780Hookney Tor20/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
col review prompted by The Fours
111787722Millstone Rigg20/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
col review prompted by The Fours
1117711518Carn Airigh Shomhairle18/07/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12274. N top has 75m contour
on OS Maps 30m N of GPS submission.
111767720Black Scar18/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
col tweak prompted by The Fours
111755615Hound Tor18/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
LIDAR review of col prompted by The Fours CC: DSM 414.3 (1m
data) but decimal dubious in terrain
1117412062Sae Breck17/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12268. ( )s justified after
site visit
1117315923Nettlehope Hill16/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
summit re evaluation prompted by The Fours
1117216092Whinfell Beacon16/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
col review prompted by The Fours
1117116537Waggonshaw Brow16/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Summit from NLS 1344.1-0.3ft = 409.6m. Prompted by The Fours
1117016368Hope Fell16/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
col review prompted by The Fours
1116916367Greenhow Hill Top16/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Col re-evaluation prompted by The Fours
11168162Sron Dha Mhurchaidh [Sron dha-Murchdi]15/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
OS consistent on name - spotted by alda. Retaining old SMC
name for search facilitation (MT deleted 1921)
11167672Meall an t-Snaim15/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
name tweak - spotted by alda
11166458Cac Carn Mor14/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
new subSimm proposed by alda. An average of Geograph and OSM
contours at col supports.
11165816Ciste Dhubh East Top14/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
name change from alda
111643186Ladhar Bheinn Far South Top14/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
name change from alda linked to previous CR
111636378Ladhar Bheinn South Top14/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
name change from alda linked to next CR
111624290Druim a' Ghoirtein Far West Top14/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
name change from alda to accommodate new subSimm identified
in previous CR
1116119404 (New)Druim a' Ghoirtein West Top14/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
new Subsimm identified and surveyed by alda. GR10 data to
follow. (CC) correcting Class code
1116010992Dun an Dubh-challa11/07/2018SEApplied
(Agree=3)
Hill name correction spotted by Darren Giddins
111593197Meall Dubh09/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12165. alda survey
11158760Meall Coire Lochain09/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12164. alda survey
11157759Meall na Teanga09/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12163. alda survey
1115612036Score Hill09/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12156 and ( )s. Site visit
111552634The Old Man of Coniston [Coniston Old Man]08/07/2018GJApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12131
111544922Ward of Clett08/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
( ) and logs
111532240Fan y Big05/07/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
Simm/Tump deletion following LIDAR analysis and survey by M
Phillips reported on the rhb group
111528622Cnoc Loch Kemp04/07/2018GGApplied
(Agree=3)
GR6 summit tweak
1115114614Bryn Gwyn02/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Catchment error spotted by Chris Watson. Deleting
Glaslyn, adding Gwyrfai
111507510Clogwynygarreg02/07/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Catchment error spotted by Chris Watson. Deleting Glaslyn,
adding Gwyrfai
111493878Horsehow Crags01/07/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
Col relocation from OS Maps prompted by The Fours. Can't
find source of old col GR8.
111482635Swirl How28/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 12018. Height change
following G&J survey
1114713273Glencaird Hill [Balraggan]27/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 12016. Summit name tweak and
relocation after visit by chrisbien, supportive log from
Dazingdale & summit Cr spot height of 1125.7ft on 1853 NLS
(at least 343m).
111463791Darling Fell27/06/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
Col tweak prompted by The Fours. OS Maps reading lower than
Geograph.
111453786Dawsonground Crags27/06/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
LIDAR analysis. Col tweak prompted by The Fours.
111443782Sourfoot Fell27/06/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
LIDAR analysis. Col tweak prompted by The Fours.
111433779Lang How27/06/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
OS Maps col tweak prompted by The Fours
111422484Burnbank Fell27/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
col re-evaluation prompted by The Fours
111413755Yew Bank27/06/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
OS Maps col tweak prompted by The Fours
111402495Fellbarrow - Mosser Fell27/06/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
LIDAR analysis. Tweak prompted by The Fours.
1113912078Head of Lambhoga24/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
OSM supports RHW's 2013 assertion that it is c P25. Tump
demotion
1113816497Hameldon23/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 11986. LIDAR analysis. Tweak
prompted by The Fours
1113716536Fox Low23/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 11985. LIDAR analysis.
Tweak prompted by The Fours
1113615951The Middle23/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 11984. LIDAR analysis.
Tweak prompted by The Fours
111357698Ether Knott23/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 11982. LIDAR analysis. Tweak
prompted by The Fours
111347901Knotts23/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 11981. LIDAR analysis.
Tweak prompted by The Fours
111337759Rock Hill23/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 11980. LIDAR analysis. Tweak
prompted by The Fours
111326381Meall Coire na Gaoithe'n Ear23/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 11979. New Simm following
alda survey
111312831Cringle Moor - Drake Howe21/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
tweak prompted by The Fours
1113019403 (New)Wether Lair21/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
New s4 identified by Myrddyn Phillips & Aled Williams in The
Fours
111292603Grayrigg Forest21/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
tweak prompted by The Fours
111282485Lingmoor Fell [Lingmoor Fell - Brown How]21/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
tweak prompted by The Fours
111272493Low Fell21/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
tweak prompted by The Fours
111266384Sgurr Coire nan Gobhar North Top18/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Name re-appraisal - linked to previous CR
111257876Sgurr nam Feadan18/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 11934. alda summit survey.
Name re-appraisal.
11124200Stob an Fhuarain18/06/2018DMApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 11923
1112311682Cats Craig17/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Tump deletion prompted by chrisbien's GPS report. Geograph
and OSM mapping conflict and the 25K col spot contradicts
its adjacent contours. 1971-75 10K supports col at 224.
Comment added.
11122324Mullach nan Coirean East Top16/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Reclassifying as Murdo after alda survey raised height to
>914.4. Missed this in 2017. Spotted by mae (still not a
Munro Top).
1112119402 (New)Creag Feusag West Top15/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
New subSimm surveyed by alda
111206549Cnoc na Moine15/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 11904. alda summit survey
111196238Sreang Glas a' Chuill15/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 11903. alda survey. Delete
Comment
111186250Carn na Saobhaidh15/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 11902. alda survey
111179272Meallan Donn14/06/2018SEApplied
(Agree=4)
Name change on both 1:25k and 1:50k, spotted by Alan Moore
1111619401 (New)Sgaraman nam Fiadh14/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
New subSimm surveyed by alda
111153138Sgaraman nam Fiadh North Top14/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Renaming to accomodate new hill 1200m SSE which has been
surveyed as a new sSim. alda survey. GR10 and Feature to
follow via GR Update 11901, not appearing automatically as I
raised a conventional CR for the name change 1st.
1111419400 (New)Carn Allt na Caime South Top10/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
New Tump
111138622Cnoc Loch Kemp09/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Topo maps confirm there is no 230m contour on 25K at
NH463166. Summit moves 700m SSE. 50K, OSM, Google all
supportive. Col height re-appraised from OSM with its 5m
contours. Renaming.
1111219399 (New)Cnoc Dubh08/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New Tump. Only 6 OSM contours but interpolates comfortably.
4 10m contours.
1111119398 (New)Druim Seangain07/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
New Tump. 7 OSM contours
1111012310Tosgaram [Torscaram]06/06/2018JimRejected
(Agree=1)
summit relocation based on
https://osmaps.ordnancesurvey.co.uk/57.93900,-6.70473,18 .
Geograph indicates 5 competing candidates but OSM shows just
one. GPSGR10 candidates at 2 alternatives.
1110919397 (New)Slieau Maggle06/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
New Manx Tump spotted by Darren Giddins
111083839Wansfell Pike03/06/2018JimApplied
(Agree=4)
Change linked to GR update ref 11736. New Tump 1st
identified by Myrddyn Phillips & Aled Williams in The Fours.
Subsequent survey by G&J.
1110711327Dun Righ31/05/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Consequent on previous CR. Eilean Righ is no longer a Mono
Tump island. Eilean Righ to be I125 (see email).
1110619396 (New)Eilean Righ North Top31/05/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
New Tump on Eilean Righ. Col interpolated at 12m (CC) The
old height is 142ft on all the 6 inch and 25 inch maps (all
pre 1900) but the correction to Newlyn is +2.3ft at this
exact location so the height should be 44(.0)m (see email)
1110519395 (New)Cruach na Gaibhre31/05/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
New Tump. 7 OSM contour rings (almost 8). Summit perhaps not
at trig point (but same GR6) - Geograph photo indicates
similar height.
https://osmaps.ordnancesurvey.co.uk/55.85926,-5.62438,18
(CC) OS Maps contouring in col region consistent with old
spot heights
11104743Sgurr an Fhuarain30/05/2018DMApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 0 Addition of GR8 for col
11103691Spidean Mialach30/05/2018DMApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 0 Addition of GR8 for col
11102689Creag Coire na Fiar Bhealaich [Craig Coire na Fiar Bhealaich]30/05/2018DMApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 11713 Addition of GR8 for
col
111019222Meall Dubh30/05/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
extra 5m contour on SE summit on OSM. Geograph agrees on
summit location. 15 OSM contours (P70++). Ignoring
Geograph's absolute height
1110028/05/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Stage 2 of ensuring that Watershed hills lie between 2
Catchments (inc Minor Rivers). Deleting Watershed status
from 8 hills. Adding 2nd Catchment to 29 hills. Correcting 3
hills from Shiel to Sunart
1109917304Broom Hill27/05/2018JimApplied
(Agree=1)
Change linked to GR update ref 11631. OSM gives a small
contour ring indicating SE summit is higher. This is c 100m
from GR10 readings in wood (which were probably influenced
by the Geograph spot height position and our GR6 for the
alternative position). See also
http://maps.nls.uk/geo/explore/#zoom=16&lat=52.0674&lon=-1.5
061&layers=10&b=1
110986077Little Conachcraig25/05/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 11609. alda survey. Demoted
to s5 from sSim
110973178Meall a' Mheanbh-chruidh25/05/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 11608. alda survey
110963176Carn Dearg25/05/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 11607. alda survey. Simm
deletion
1109519199Druim Fiaclach East Top25/05/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 11606. alda survey. New Simm
11094717Druim Fiaclach25/05/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 11605. alda summit survey
110937725Great Haw23/05/2018GGApplied
(Agree=3)
height change based on 50K and old maps
1109213994Dumfedling Hill23/05/2018SEApplied
(Agree=4)
Correcting hillname - spotted by Chris Bienkowski
1109114639Moelfryn22/05/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Associated with previous 2 CRs. Adding Gwyrfai.
110902008Mynydd Drws-y-coed22/05/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Associated with previous CR - also in Gwyrfai. New Triple
too.
110892026Y Garn22/05/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Catchment error - Llyn y Gader is the start of the Gwyrfai
(does not flow S into Glaslyn)
110889539Cnoc Blar an Dubhaidh22/05/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Swapping alternative summits. OSMaps gives an extra, tiny
contour ring to new candidate. No logs. Height left
unchanged - using OSM for guidance.
110874286Meall an Spardain21/05/2018DMApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 11593. alda survey
110866479An Elric21/05/2018DMApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 11592. alda survey
11085874Carn a' Mhadaidh-ruaidh [Sail Chaorainn]21/05/2018DMApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 11591. alda survey CC:
adding Subsimm classification, moving old name from Comments
110846376Sgurr a' Choire-bheithe Far East Top21/05/2018DMApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 11590. alda survey
1108319394 (New)Spurn Island20/05/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
new Main SIB added to Version 5 of Alan Holmes' publication.
See email
110827886Leac nan Gaidhseich19/05/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 11509. alda survey
1108110866Cnoc Buidhe North Top17/05/2018GGApplied
(Agree=3)
correcting summit height
1108016587Weaver Hills14/05/2018CCApplied
(Agree=2)
col tweak (assumes summit above 19384 Hemmings Low)
110796123Cock Hill13/05/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 11443. alda survey
11078892Sgurr Choinnich13/05/2018DMApplied
(Agree=3)
Addition of GR8 for col
1107714369Cefn Hir-fynydd10/05/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 11423 - LIDAR study
1107619393 (New)Hatfield Colliery08/05/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
Reclaimed spoil tip identified from SRTM data, promoted
after site visit by Rob Woodall. Ground 200m E at SE 656117
is 0.2m lower in LIDAR. RW's GR10 to be entered (LIDAR
summit 20m E)
1107514527Bryn08/05/2018CCApplied
(Agree=2)
Relocation prompted by Myrddyn Phillips report. Data from
LIDAR, col 277.0.
1107410007Creag an Lochain Duibh07/05/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
relocation and renaming
1107319392 (New)Carn Loch Sian07/05/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
New Tump. 7 contours on OSMap. Name invented
1107218979Windmill Hill07/05/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
correcting Section
11071SK458481Dirt Hill (Eastwood)07/05/2018CCRejected
(Agree=2)
Reclaimed slag heap, Tump suggestion from Rich Wiles. P29 in
LIDAR and Google Earth. Rob W visit suggests 133m spot/130m
contour erroneous, see emails.
11070SE326196Lowe Hill07/05/2018CCRejected
(Agree=3)
Tump suggestion from Paul Grantham. P27 in LIDAR
1106916515Upper Edge07/05/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
col tweak from OS Maps
1106817926Winsford Hill07/05/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
428m tumulus not on natural summit. Trig FB 427.46, LIDAR
426.7 with ground 30m E 427.1m. N col 348.9 DTM, 351 DSM
(road surface). 341 spot inconsistent with LIDAR; old map
has 351m BM nearby. S col 349.3m at SS843377.
110673769The Benn [Sippling Crag]07/05/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
LIDAR update. DSM preferred for summit crag.
11066NY713013Knott07/05/2018JimRejected
(Agree=2)
In 'The Fours'. OSMaps suggest this is optimistic.
1106519391 (New)Green Hill06/05/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
New Tump identified by Myrddyn Phillips/Aled Williams in
'The Fours'. LIDAR study
1106419390 (New)Mozie Law South Top06/05/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
New Tump identified by Myrddyn Phillips & Aled Williams in
'The Fours'. Interpolated col from OSMaps
1106316530High Moor05/05/2018CCApplied
(Agree=2)
Height changes. LIDAR N summit 415.8, S summit >415.7
(incomplete coverage) surveyed by Abney as higher. Col 384.0
in dense conifer plantation.
1106216357Black Hill05/05/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 11364. Tump deletion first
identified by Myrddyn Phillips/Aled Williams. LIDAR analysis
confirms.
1106119389 (New)Carn Mor NE Top05/05/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
New tump spotted by chalky1953. Unnamed on maps.
Interpolation from OSMaps
1106016097Beacon Hill04/05/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Suggestion in 'The Fours' that this is less than P30.
However it has 7 contours on OSMaps. Minor adjustment to col
position. Preferring levelled(50K) height.
110592499Silver How04/05/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Drop understated. OSMaps has 7 contours. Identified by
Myrddyn Phillips/Aled Williams in 'The Fours'. New Tump
110586817Cnoc na h-Innse Moire02/05/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Request for prominence clarity following public emails in
June 2017.
1105719388 (New)Scoop Hill02/05/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
new tump spotted by Dave Geere
110563839Wansfell Pike01/05/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 11309 and site visit to
competing cols. Hill awaiting survey following inclusion in
'The Fours' by Myrddyn Phillips & Aled Williams.
110556729Creag Deabharan26/04/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 11304. alda survey
110549123An Carnan [Beinn nan Ramh West Top]25/04/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Now named by OS at all scales - spotted by alda
110531284Beinn na Cro [Ben na Cro]24/04/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Swapping name order - anglicised name no longer appears on
OS mapping
11052278Ben Nevis [Beinn Nibheis]23/04/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
gaelic name now appears at all OS scales
110511980Moel Siabod22/04/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 11292. Separate surveys of
col and summit by Myrddyn Phillips/Mark Trengove/Aled
Williams. P600 deletion
110504486Meall Meadhonach22/04/2018DMApplied
(Agree=2)
Addition of GR10 for col
110494488Meall Meadhonach West Top22/04/2018DMApplied
(Agree=2)
Addition of GR10 for col
1104819387 (New)Conival North Top21/04/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
new sSim surveyed by alda.
1104719386 (New)Beinn an Fhurain21/04/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
new sSim surveyed by alda who reports, 'The 788m spot height
[near col] is a knoll'.
110464480Meall nan Caorach21/04/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 11266. alda survey
110453289Na Tuadhan21/04/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 11264. alda survey. alda
reports that the loch by the col has a westerly outflow -
hence his col position
110445380Birdlip Hill17/04/2018CCApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 11242; summit identified from
LIDAR and satellite image
11043SO822019Bown Hill17/04/2018CCRejected
(Agree=1)
Tump SE of Stroud, Glos, suggested by Charles Everett. P29
in LIDAR.
11042SH660165Coed-y-garth SW Top16/04/2018CCRejected
(Agree=1)
Tump candidate SW of 14825 Coed-y-Garth rejected on LIDAR.
Raised by RHW as originally a P31 hill in Myrddyn Phillips'
list.
11041SN985950Allt y Genlli16/04/2018GJRejected
(Agree=2)
Survey of Allt y Genlli using Leica Viva GS15 receiver and
Leica NA730 level and staff. Summit grid reference is SN
98510 95045 (Garmin).
11040NM639572Druim Nan Sgalag14/04/2018JimRejected
(Agree=1)
Potential Tump candidate suggested by chalky1953 after site
visit. Rejected on the basis of the OSMap 5m contours - col
interpolated
110393098The Snub11/04/2018DMApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 11160. Addition of decimal
height for summit and decimal height and GR8 for col from
Alan Dawson survey.
110383051Beinn Bhreac NW Top11/04/2018DMApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 11159. Addition of decimal
height for summit from Alan Dawson survey.
110375980An Sligearnach11/04/2018DMApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 11158. Addition of decimal
height for summit and decimal height and GR8 for col from
Alan Dawson survey
11036437Carn nan Sac10/04/2018DMApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 11157. Addition of decimal
height for summit and decimal height and GR8 for col from
Alan Dawson survey.
110353069Carn Mor10/04/2018DMApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 11156. Addition of col GR
and height and decimal summit height from Alan Dawson
survey.
1103419339Meall Lochan Loin nan Donnlaich10/04/2018DMApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 11155. Addition of col GR and
height and change to summit height from Alan Dawson survey.
Jim: changing Comment
110335882Meall a' Bhuige10/04/2018DMApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 11154. Addition of decimal
height for summit and col from Alan Dawson survey.
1103215031Mynydd Garth-pwt08/04/2018GJApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 11144
110315978Braigh Clais Daimh06/04/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 11123. alda survey
110307170Scars of Milldown06/04/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 11122. alda survey
110293009Beinn a' Bhric06/04/2018DMApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 11121. alda survey.
1102814602Tarren Fach05/04/2018DMApplied
(Agree=3)
Change linked to GR update ref 11109. Addition of decimal
height for summit and col GR and height from LIDAR.
110275774Maol a' Chapuill05/04/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 11102. alda survey.
1102656Beinn Uamha05/04/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 11103. alda survey
110255770Cruachan South Top05/04/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 11101. alda survey
110244582Cruachan05/04/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 11100. alda survey.
110232291Mynydd Gethin04/04/2018CCApplied
(Agree=2)
Col from LIDAR. DTM summit 491.5m in forest 8m ENE of trig,
disinclined to relocate/reheight without evidence on the
ground.
110221117Beinn Dearg04/04/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
Revision prompted by alda from col on OSMaps - Geograph 277
spot contradicts unless mound. Old trig 423.4m at summit.
11021336Meall a' Bhainne04/04/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
alda OSMaps interp
110202062Rhinog Fach04/04/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
alda OSMaps interp
110192834Eston Nab04/04/2018CCApplied
(Agree=2)
LIDAR at summit and col, drop rounds to 148.0
110181545Faan Hill04/04/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
Col re-evaluated from OSMaps 5m contours, spotted by alda.
Drop adjusted for difference from Geograph at summit.
110172225Middleton Hill04/04/2018CCApplied
(Agree=2)
LIDAR at summit 204.68 (2m data), FB-0.4m = 205.86, mean
taken.
1101619385 (New)Tom na h-Eilde04/04/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
new noughty spotted by alda. Data mixed from OSM/Geograph
but 40m contour position near col is within 6 horizontal
metres.
110152224Brandy Hill04/04/2018CCApplied
(Agree=2)
LIDAR at col, accuracy and location compromised by trees but
estimate 53m max. Suggests natural summit may be 205.1m in
field 20m S of hedge bearing trig (FB 206.05).
110142820Freeholds Top04/04/2018CCApplied
(Agree=2)
LIDAR data at col. Mapping and old trig suggest slightly
higher ground possible to E or S of summit but no LIDAR or
Abney.
110132169Disgwylfa Fawr04/04/2018CCApplied
(Agree=2)
LIDAR data at col. Summit 506.2m on old maps, same tumulus
location so case for reducing height.
110125772Meall a' Chapuill04/04/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 11097. alda survey.
110115780Stron Lochie04/04/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 11096. alda survey. Dodd
demotion. Col reinterpolated after consideration of
Geograph/OSMaps/new summit height.
1101015371Copa Shon04/04/2018CCApplied
(Agree=2)
Col swap with 7595 prompted by M Phillips survey. Data from
LIDAR.
110097595Pen y Graig-fawr04/04/2018CCApplied
(Agree=2)
Subhump deletion and col swap with 15371 prompted by M
Phillips survey. Data from LIDAR.
110087644Gornoeth01/04/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
removing decimal height after consulting survey result
1100726/03/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Dealing with 14 further hills where Catchment status is not
now compatible with Watershed status. Watershed hills must
be Doubles/Triples except where they interact with a Minor
River catchment. See simonchanges180326.xlsx
1100619378Stac a' Bhagh24/03/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Col GR incorrectly formatted
110053128Carn Leac23/03/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
adding Lochy & Triples
11004104Beinn a' Chreachain22/03/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
not in Awe >140m, therefore deleting Watersheds
11003173Beinn Chaorach22/03/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Watersheds removal >130m
1100287Meall Odhar22/03/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
>100m from Watersheds
110018099Sgiath an Iubhair22/03/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
adding Leven (Dunbarton)
1100056Beinn Uamha22/03/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
deleting all Watershed entries. >100m to Leven (Dunbarton)
109993276Creag Bac na Faire22/03/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
adding Cromarty catchment and 6XWatersheds
109981073Beinn Enaiglair22/03/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
removing 6XWatersheds; Cromarty >100m
1099717458Brands Hill22/03/2018GGApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 10983: height from LIDAR data
109969259Meall nan Uan20/03/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Removing from 6XWatersheds - summit >100m from precise
Dornoch catchment boundary (site visit today)
1099513171Manquhill Hill19/03/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
replacing Nith Catchment - spotted by Chris Ottley
1099421Beinn Dearg19/03/2018GJApplied
(Agree=4)
Change linked to GR update ref 10953
109931102Beinn Tharsuinn19/03/2018GJApplied
(Agree=4)
Change linked to GR update ref 10951
1099118985Cauldon Lowe18/03/2018CCApplied
(Agree=2)
Relocation of col and Tump deletion following promotion of
Hemmings Low, see emails.
1099019384 (New)Hemmings Low18/03/2018CCApplied
(Agree=2)
New Tump near W edge of Cauldon Low Quarry proposed by
Darren Giddins. Col assumes summit lower than 16587 Weaver
Hills (372m) and col linking to 18985 Cauldon Lowe is
higher.
10989SK458481Brinsley Hill18/03/2018GGRejected
(Agree=2)
new Tump suggested by Rich Wiles, rejected on LIDAR data and
site report by Darren Giddins
1098819383 (New)Burstheart Hill [Thoresby Colliery]18/03/2018GGApplied
(Agree=2)
new spoil heap Tump suggested by Stephen Walker & Adrian
Rayner
109871282Beinn Dearg Mhor15/03/2018DMApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 10912. Addition of GR8 for
col.
109864797Beinn Dearg Bheag15/03/2018DMApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 10913. Addition of GR8 for
col.
109857799The Mount11/03/2018CCApplied
(Agree=2)
Adding LIDAR data. Summit move. Col position in railway
cutting confirmed - we guessed well before!
109845194Llechwedd y Glyn09/03/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
Adding LIDAR height
109833534Mynydd Caerau07/03/2018CCApplied
(Agree=4)
Subhump deletion and summit move from LIDAR
109829636Cnoc Maol Malpelly07/03/2018SEApplied
(Agree=3)
Should be in 16C (spotted by Andrew Tibbetts)
109815317Hoof Stones Height [Black Hameldon]06/03/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
Hump deletion based on LIDAR data
1098019053St Catherine's Island06/03/2018CCApplied
(Agree=4)
update from LIDAR
1097912121Birka Stack05/03/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Tump deletion, OSMap shows col >20m
1097818859Hope's Heugh Stack04/03/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Tump deletion. Looks stack like from ESE but closer
examination, from SSE, reveals it to be connected to the
Mainland about 3m below its summit. Alternative feature,
suggested by OS, 75m SE is merely a grass slope beneath
cliffs (no channel disconnects it from the Mainland). Thanks
to Smudge & RHW for pics. Height estimated from camera
angles cf 37m Skelly
1097717445Leopard Hill04/03/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
Tump deletion after replacement by Leopard Hill, see
CR10976. Data from LIDAR. (Simon edit comment when hill no.
known)
1097619382 (New)Elbury Hill04/03/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
New Tump identified by Myrddyn Phillips, replacing 17445
Leopard Hill which is 0.16m lower by LIDAR.
1097517129Crabtree Hill03/03/2018JimRejected
(Agree=1)
potential relocation or demotion
1097418800Gearran Island02/03/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Tump deletion. Review of photographic and mapping evidence
following RHW's claim that this is not a separate island.
Satellite imagery most telling. Leaving name unchanged.
SIMON - please delete Area entry - should be 'blank'
1097318350Blackwater Hill01/03/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 10842. LIDAR study after
query from Charles Everett. Original col intact to E of road
cutting so not a Tump reinstatement
109725858Creag an t-Searraich28/02/2018DMApplied
(Agree=4)
Change linked to GR update ref 10839. Added decimal height
from Leica RX1250 measurement and decimal height for col
from same instrument.
1097127/02/2018JimApplied
(Agree=3)
Request to show St Abbs's stacks on HB to GR8
position 14316 NT 9077 6944 14315 NT 9096 6954 18859 NT
9100 6948 18860 NT 9115 6940 14314 NT 9119 6943 18861 NT
9133 6938 18862 NT 9092 6952
10970SK532503Linby Hill [The Ranges]27/02/2018CCRejected
(Agree=1)
Tump candidate in Nottinghamshire suggested by Darren
Giddins, LIDAR P28.7
109695574Horsenden Hill27/02/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Change linked to GR update ref 10808. Summit LIDARed. SIMON
delete Comment
1096819381 (New)Thorn Hill27/02/2018CCApplied
(Agree=4)
New Tump in Somerset suggested by Chris Pearson. Data from
LIDAR
1096719380 (New)Gale Common27/02/2018GGApplied
(Agree=3)
new artificial hill Tump from SRTM and LIDAR analysis. Site
visit by Rob Woodall confirms Tump worthiness
1096615576Ynys Gwelltog27/02/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ynys_Gwelltog#/media/File:Ynys
_Gwelltog_from_Ramsey.png green slime on col rocks, so leave
at 1m. Please transfer from Z14 to Z07
1096519379 (New)Wilderness Tip (Gresford)26/02/2018CCApplied
(Agree=3)
New Tump from colliery spoil identified by Myrddyn Phillips.
Data from LIDAR, name from Wrexham Council and Gresford
Community Council publications.
1096415576Ynys Gwelltog25/02/2018JimRejected
(Agree=1)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ynys_Gwelltog#/media/File:Ynys
_Gwelltog_from_Ramsey.png green slime on col rocks, so leave
at 1m.
1096318778Stac Geodh' Mhanaich25/02/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
col well defined on OSMaps
1096219378 (New)Stac a' Bhagh25/02/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
New Tump on Neave island (a 2nd attached seastack). Named
after adjacent feature.
1096111537Brosdale Island25/02/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Incorrect Topo Region - please transfer from Z11 to Z10
109607003Beinn Oronsay25/02/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Changing topographical status (col height is 1m). Transfer
from Z11 to Z05
1095912071The Ward25/02/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
minor adjustment to col height (above MHWS)
1095810553Eilean Didil25/02/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Changing topographical status (col height is 1m). No
Parent Ma but please move from Z10 to Y04
1095710540Corr Eilean25/02/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Changing topographical status (col height is 1m). No
Parent Ma but please move from Z10 to Y04
1095610496Macleod's Maidens24/02/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
http://www.geograph.org.uk/photo/3399846 http://www.geograp
h.org.uk/photo/1457508 No compelling case that col is 1m.
0m (or <0m) more likely perhaps (CC) boulder hop at low
tide according
to https://www.ukclimbing.com/logbook/crag.php?id=17764
1095512782Orasaigh24/02/2018JimApplied
(Agree=2)
Changing topographical status (col height is 2m). Simon
please ensure transfer from Z09 to X06. Reducing col height
to 1m as mean springs tidal range is only 4m